Is America guilty of bowling alone? Are we missing vital social capital to keep our democracy alive? Are we turning towards Tocqueville's soft despotism (turning inward and selfish)? Why...
4 comments:
Anonymous
said...
I think that while we have been bowling alone for awhile, we will seen in the next few years less people bowling alone. Think about all the clubs we have at Stevenson. Extra-curriculars are heavily stressed in high schools and colleges, so I think by the time people in our generation become adults, less people will be bowling alone. To answer Inf, teachers probably don't want to be judged by their political views. Plus, I think it is good that we are encouraged to make our own decisions, not have them forced upon us by persuasive teachers.
America is gulity of bowling alone. Back even 30 years ago you would see people being much more involved in their society. Today how many people can you honestly say you know that go to PTA meetings or are invoved in community orgnaizations. People act as though they just live in the community but dont want to have any part in decisons made for it. I also beleive that todays world is much different than it was 30 years ago. Today we have the internet in which people can communicate without ever seing eachother. It does seem as thoguh people are more indepentdent than they used to be, but when the country is in need people are always coming to help, like the hurrican or even spiit walk for example, when people know others are in need they are willing to work together which is the first step in helping to get the society to "bowl together" once again
Well, yea i agree America is guilty for bowling alone. But i don't know how many people know about political involvement internationally, because from what i see and experienced, America has a stronger participation in politics,local meetings and institutions such as the PTA. Yes, we criticize about how many young adults don't vote and I agree with that point. I am not saying we don't have to worry about how America is guilty for bowling alone. But we also got to apprecicate the people that DO get involved in order to voice their opinions, and DO make a difference by participating.
Wow, what a seemingly cynical bunch. Well, I'd rather think of you all as cynics than thinking that our nation is in as much trouble as the majority seems to believe.
Though it may seem at first that social capital in America has dissapeared, I think that it has simply mutated because of new technology. People say that it is horrible, how technology is minimalizing the amount of human contact that occurs, and of course, human contact is always the best way to share ideas, but the internet has many advantages. The power of social capital in the form of PTAs, boy scouts, and other groups described in the article is that it allows similarly minded people to get together, discuss their problems, see what needs changing, and then work together to affect their changes in the government. The problem we see now is that less people are going to these organized groups. What most of us fail to notice is that many unofficial groups are coming together. School clubs, and routine friendly gatherings are a perfect example of social capital that is often overlooked. Technology has also provided a new medium for such loose orginizations. Not only has the internet made it easier to keep up to date with the news, but it has also made it far simpler to express one's opinions to a large number of people. Blogs like this and many other, less organized ones are a perfect example of political discussion that would otherwise be limitted by having a short time to think of things to say (it took me almost three days to come up with a response to this issue) it gives the writer a chance to organize and clarify their thoughts instead of stating simply what comes to mind,and it even allows the ideas of relatively quiet people to speak as loudly as anybody else's. Though the topics discussed here tend to be abstract and faraway, many blogs play host to discussion about local problems, and instant messaging can serve a similar purpose. Technology, though it may at times distract us from our problems, will not destroy social capital, technology simply relocates it. As Ben said, perhaps we are not bowling in leagues anymore, such rigid organization is not always best for everybody, perhaps now it is a time where the best bowling is just a game with friends, a game that can take place at any time, at any place, and include anybody.
As to Tocqueville's soft despotism, it seems to me that in times of need, Americans are always willing to help those that need it. September 11th, the Tsunami, and huricane Katrina are clear examples that tell me that Americans are not completely inward and selfish. Even in the face of quickly rising gas prices, Americans gave their money away to the victims of Katrina. Then again, a certain amount of selfishness doesn't always hurt. The framers of the Constitution designed the American system so that a large variety of selfish goals would end up cancelling themselves out.
To further elaborate on lnf's question about why teachers don't reveal their political standings, I believe that teachers have a great amount of sway over the opinions of the students, for example, in Acc. Biology freshman year, Mr. Carmichael told my class that Guided Evolution (aka Intelligent design) was a rediculous theory, and not a person in the class argued against him. We were taught that global warming was 100% real, and definately bad, and everybody believed it without a doubt when Mr. Carmichael said it, and again when Mr. Urick explained it to our class in Acc. Chemistry. We never thought to question our teachers, everything that they must be true. Years later, I believe in Intelligent design, and though I admit that global warming is happening, and that there is more CO2 in the atmosphere than there had been in the past, nobody really knows whether this is human caused, or whether it is even definately a bad thing. It took me years to realize that the opinions of the teacher (great as the teachers are) do not match my beliefs. A teacher, especially of government and history, that reveals his/her political preference could change the student's beliefs without the student knowing what is right for him/herself. It's a great thing that teachers allow us to make up our own minds on such issues, without first polluting our thoughts with their opinions. But I don't think it's wrong for a teacher to reveal his/her political standing after allowing the students to form their own opinions on a subject.
4 comments:
I think that while we have been bowling alone for awhile, we will seen in the next few years less people bowling alone. Think about all the clubs we have at Stevenson. Extra-curriculars are heavily stressed in high schools and colleges, so I think by the time people in our generation become adults, less people will be bowling alone.
To answer Inf, teachers probably don't want to be judged by their political views. Plus, I think it is good that we are encouraged to make our own decisions, not have them forced upon us by persuasive teachers.
America is gulity of bowling alone. Back even 30 years ago you would see people being much more involved in their society. Today how many people can you honestly say you know that go to PTA meetings or are invoved in community orgnaizations. People act as though they just live in the community but dont want to have any part in decisons made for it. I also beleive that todays world is much different than it was 30 years ago. Today we have the internet in which people can communicate without ever seing eachother. It does seem as thoguh people are more indepentdent than they used to be, but when the country is in need people are always coming to help, like the hurrican or even spiit walk for example, when people know others are in need they are willing to work together which is the first step in helping to get the society to "bowl together" once again
Well, yea i agree America is guilty for bowling alone. But i don't know how many people know about political involvement internationally, because from what i see and experienced, America has a stronger participation in politics,local meetings and institutions such as the PTA.
Yes, we criticize about how many young adults don't vote and I agree with that point. I am not saying we don't have to worry about how America is guilty for bowling alone. But we also got to apprecicate the people that DO get involved in order to voice their opinions, and DO make a difference by participating.
Wow, what a seemingly cynical bunch. Well, I'd rather think of you all as cynics than thinking that our nation is in as much trouble as the majority seems to believe.
Though it may seem at first that social capital in America has dissapeared, I think that it has simply mutated because of new technology. People say that it is horrible, how technology is minimalizing the amount of human contact that occurs, and of course, human contact is always the best way to share ideas, but the internet has many advantages.
The power of social capital in the form of PTAs, boy scouts, and other groups described in the article is that it allows similarly minded people to get together, discuss their problems, see what needs changing, and then work together to affect their changes in the government. The problem we see now is that less people are going to these organized groups. What most of us fail to notice is that many unofficial groups are coming together. School clubs, and routine friendly gatherings are a perfect example of social capital that is often overlooked. Technology has also provided a new medium for such loose orginizations. Not only has the internet made it easier to keep up to date with the news, but it has also made it far simpler to express one's opinions to a large number of people. Blogs like this and many other, less organized ones are a perfect example of political discussion that would otherwise be limitted by having a short time to think of things to say (it took me almost three days to come up with a response to this issue) it gives the writer a chance to organize and clarify their thoughts instead of stating simply what comes to mind,and it even allows the ideas of relatively quiet people to speak as loudly as anybody else's. Though the topics discussed here tend to be abstract and faraway, many blogs play host to discussion about local problems, and instant messaging can serve a similar purpose. Technology, though it may at times distract us from our problems, will not destroy social capital, technology simply relocates it. As Ben said, perhaps we are not bowling in leagues anymore, such rigid organization is not always best for everybody, perhaps now it is a time where the best bowling is just a game with friends, a game that can take place at any time, at any place, and include anybody.
As to Tocqueville's soft despotism, it seems to me that in times of need, Americans are always willing to help those that need it. September 11th, the Tsunami, and huricane Katrina are clear examples that tell me that Americans are not completely inward and selfish. Even in the face of quickly rising gas prices, Americans gave their money away to the victims of Katrina. Then again, a certain amount of selfishness doesn't always hurt. The framers of the Constitution designed the American system so that a large variety of selfish goals would end up cancelling themselves out.
To further elaborate on lnf's question about why teachers don't reveal their political standings, I believe that teachers have a great amount of sway over the opinions of the students, for example, in Acc. Biology freshman year, Mr. Carmichael told my class that Guided Evolution (aka Intelligent design) was a rediculous theory, and not a person in the class argued against him. We were taught that global warming was 100% real, and definately bad, and everybody believed it without a doubt when Mr. Carmichael said it, and again when Mr. Urick explained it to our class in Acc. Chemistry. We never thought to question our teachers, everything that they must be true. Years later, I believe in Intelligent design, and though I admit that global warming is happening, and that there is more CO2 in the atmosphere than there had been in the past, nobody really knows whether this is human caused, or whether it is even definately a bad thing. It took me years to realize that the opinions of the teacher (great as the teachers are) do not match my beliefs. A teacher, especially of government and history, that reveals his/her political preference could change the student's beliefs without the student knowing what is right for him/herself. It's a great thing that teachers allow us to make up our own minds on such issues, without first polluting our thoughts with their opinions. But I don't think it's wrong for a teacher to reveal his/her political standing after allowing the students to form their own opinions on a subject.
Post a Comment