A 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Judge once again argued that reciting the pledge violates the establishment clause of the First Amendment... Do you agree? Or is it a part of our Cultural Heritage? Explain...
The establishment clause of the First Amendment, creating a separation between church and state, is almost paradoxical in its desire to keep individuals free from the infringements of religious ideals – yet in the same sense limiting those religious ideals from being expressed – a limit on the right to free speech. In this sense, the job of the judicial branch to interpret these sometimes convoluted laws can be difficult – but to believe that reciting the pledge of allegiance is something that violates the first amendment because it contains the phrase “one nation under God” is, in my opinion, going too far.
Sure, prohibiting direct funding by the state to religious schools or limiting the influence of religious institutions in the government [an institution with secular aims] are both valid ways of interpreting the establishment clause, limiting people from expressing their own religious beliefs, even when they aren’t imposed on anyone else, should not be legacy of the establishment clause. When an individual says the pledge they do so voluntarily, even in the more extreme case of student led prayer – such activities are open to those who wish to participate – limiting these activities therefore appears to infringe more on the right of individuals to express themselves.
The religious affiliation of the pledge itself is ambiguous – I mean, if it we are to follow such a precedent should the president be censored for his references to God in his speeches? Should people be kept from singing God Bless America or putting Christmas trees and other symbols of religious holidays out on public display: in front of libraries, in schools, or any other institutions? Could we stop the outburst from kids after Halloween has been cancelled for its pagan influences? This is exactly where the line is blurred – such seemingly religiously affiliated trends have become so integrated into our culture as to be stripped of religious significance and either made into vast marketing gimmicks [unfortunately for most holidays] or events where religion isn’t the emphasis as much as an overarching ideal of unity or solidarity [the true meaning of the pledge, in my opinoin]
I don't believe that the pledge is unconstitutional in any way. Perhaps its use in elementary school should be more limitted, but I doubt that is necessary. However, the the phrase "under God" was not a part of the original pledge of allegiance. It was added during the Cold War to differentiate America from the atheist government of the Soviet Union. While the rest of the pledge is part of our cultural heritage, whether that particular phrase is also part of our heritage is in question.
hmm...i hate to just repeat what people have already said..but i mostly agree with everyone~ i mean the pledge isn't something that should be forced to do... i always stand up for my pledge, but more than half of my class doesn't...but tht doesn't mean that those people don't respect and love America...they're more lazy than unpatriotic...
and about the "under god" phrase..yea when i heard the pledge for tha first time when i came to the US, i was wondering if that phrase ever did or will cause controversy....it's reasonable that atheist don't agree to it. but i personally don't believe that the pledge is unconstitutional just because of that short phrase...it doesn't really specify which god it is, and even for those who don't believe in god, most people believe someone out there, who is more powerful than humans, do exist..
4 comments:
The establishment clause of the First Amendment, creating a separation between church and state, is almost paradoxical in its desire to keep individuals free from the infringements of religious ideals – yet in the same sense limiting those religious ideals from being expressed – a limit on the right to free speech. In this sense, the job of the judicial branch to interpret these sometimes convoluted laws can be difficult – but to believe that reciting the pledge of allegiance is something that violates the first amendment because it contains the phrase “one nation under God” is, in my opinion, going too far.
Sure, prohibiting direct funding by the state to religious schools or limiting the influence of religious institutions in the government [an institution with secular aims] are both valid ways of interpreting the establishment clause, limiting people from expressing their own religious beliefs, even when they aren’t imposed on anyone else, should not be legacy of the establishment clause. When an individual says the pledge they do so voluntarily, even in the more extreme case of student led prayer – such activities are open to those who wish to participate – limiting these activities therefore appears to infringe more on the right of individuals to express themselves.
The religious affiliation of the pledge itself is ambiguous – I mean, if it we are to follow such a precedent should the president be censored for his references to God in his speeches? Should people be kept from singing God Bless America or putting Christmas trees and other symbols of religious holidays out on public display: in front of libraries, in schools, or any other institutions? Could we stop the outburst from kids after Halloween has been cancelled for its pagan influences? This is exactly where the line is blurred – such seemingly religiously affiliated trends have become so integrated into our culture as to be stripped of religious significance and either made into vast marketing gimmicks [unfortunately for most holidays] or events where religion isn’t the emphasis as much as an overarching ideal of unity or solidarity [the true meaning of the pledge, in my opinoin]
Agnes Mazur *
I don't believe that the pledge is unconstitutional in any way. Perhaps its use in elementary school should be more limitted, but I doubt that is necessary. However, the the phrase "under God" was not a part of the original pledge of allegiance. It was added during the Cold War to differentiate America from the atheist government of the Soviet Union. While the rest of the pledge is part of our cultural heritage, whether that particular phrase is also part of our heritage is in question.
hmm...i hate to just repeat what people have already said..but i mostly agree with everyone~
i mean the pledge isn't something that should be forced to do...
i always stand up for my pledge, but more than half of my class doesn't...but tht doesn't mean that those people don't respect and love America...they're more lazy than unpatriotic...
and about the "under god" phrase..yea when i heard the pledge for tha first time when i came to the US, i was wondering if that phrase ever did or will cause controversy....it's reasonable that atheist don't agree to it. but i personally don't believe that the pledge is unconstitutional just because of that short phrase...it doesn't really specify which god it is, and even for those who don't believe in god, most people believe someone out there, who is more powerful than humans, do exist..
Post a Comment