Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Wednesday, February 22, 2006

Ports

Should the US allow the United Arab Emirates to have control of six ports???
Why? Why not?

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

For the safety of the United States, I don't think it is the greatest idea to allow the United Arab Emirates to control 6 of our major ports. I read an article recently that discussed this debate. Bush's argument in favor of this transition used the fact that Britain already had control over these 6 ports as evidence. However, I don't think that's valid support, seeing as how we have been allies with Britain since the 1800s. It is incomparable, therefore it cannot be done. I think it is hypocritical of Bush to grant the United Arab Emirates control over our ports, and then wonder why there are terrorists living in the United States. Now, I'm not saying that the UAE will use our ports for the wrong reasons, or that every Arab is a terrorist, don't get me wrong. And I do understand Bush's reasoning that it will improve our relations in the middle East, however I don't think that giving up our ports to people we already don't trust is a smart idea.

Anonymous said...

This is a really dumb idea. First of all, Americans should be defending American ports. Not Arabs, not French, not Italians, not English. Number two, this is like fighting fire with more fire. I do not trust these people. Call it whatever you like, now is not the time to show these people that we trust them. Third- we have some of the best law enforcement around. Why are we going to rely on the middle east to provide policeing when American cops are being paid 172 g's a year just to train arabs in policeing tactics. My respect for President Bush has decreased significantly for even bringing up this ludicrous idea. This is not the path we should go down.

Anonymous said...

I disagree with almost every point made here. This organization has a security record far better than most countries in the world Sure you could say the United Arab Emirates was home to two of the Sept. 11 hijackers and that money has been siphoned through to fund terrorists, but money has been siphoned through Switzerland, and even US money has been used against us.
"In reality, it's just an economic transaction," said Rob Quartel, chairman and CEO of Freightdesk Technologies and a former U.S. federal maritime commissioner. Dubai Ports is buying control of a company that has contracts to manage certain port terminals, said Quartel. "When all is said and done, it's going to be the same people running the [terminals] day to day, the same managers managing it. The managers' managers will report to a different board, but it's the same people."
Also this isn’t the first foreign ownership of a port. ‘And it's not far-fetched to think that terrorists might gain key knowledge to port operations and layouts through private or state-owned foreign companies. Foreign ownership of terminal operations has been going on for sometime, says Flynn. "That's why I think there's legitimate angst on Capitol Hill. We're now realizing that many of the infrastructures we took for granted as purely commercial, we're realizing are truly national security assets."’
"If the American politicians were smart, they would hold Dubai up as a role model," said Abdulla. "We don't like the tone of this. Many of us see a hint of racism there, disguised as security concern." And this is so true. Anyone who doesn’t believe there is, “a hint of racism there, disguised as security concern." Is just playing deaf and dumb or is just blindly ignorant.
That’s It, I’m Awesome, Peace.

SteveDave

Anonymous said...

I do not think that the United Arab Emirates should have control of the ports. I heard that two of the 9-11 terrorists were from the UAE. Letting a terrorist-known country control the ports would look wrong. I think there would be a great chance for another terrorist attack on the US. Why should the US make itself vulnerable? Allowing a terrorist country to have access to the ports just sounds wrong. I think it would be better to allow a different country to control the ports.

Anonymous said...

I think most of the people posting here don't exactly understand what the situation is. These ports have, until recently, been run by company in the UK, so obviously we have no problem letting foreign firms run our ports. But the key thing here is that we're talking about foreign COMPANIES, not COUNTRIES. This is purely a business transaction. It's a byproduct of globalization. There's plenty of examples of the United States outsourcing some other country to help run something here... as long as it's economically feasible, what's the problem? If you support a free market economy, then you should see nothing wrong with this. Also, it's not as if we're turning over security to this company... the Coast Guard, FBI, etc. are still taking care of all of that. We're just outsourcing the financial managing of the ports. That's equivalent to hiring a CPA to do your taxes because you don't know how to do them yourself, or at least not well enough.

This issue has been politicized and racism has unfortunately entered the equation. These aren't fanaticals, they're businesspeople who will know how to take care of the ports. Why does it matter where they're from as long as they get the job done? And why are you all letting the actions of a small minority speak for the rest of the people in the country? Notice that I said "people in the country" rather than just "the country" to emphasize the fact that this is purely a business activity, not a political move. And even if it was the UAE government, who cares? The Emirates is both a highly westernized nation and one of our greatest allies in the Middle East. Oh how quickly we brand any Arab country as a nation of radicals.

This is one case where public opinion should NOT dictate policy, because nobody here has any idea what they're talking about, except Bobby Harvey, dabrownsensation, anonymous, gluskin, and tnaz. I'd like to say that the rest of you are just uninformed, but I'm seeing some very serious indicators of racism here.

Anonymous said...

im pretty sure that fightagainstthewall was being sarcastic to make a point

Anonymous said...

It is important to note that while these 6 ports in questions were under control of a British company, the US was still in charge of security. As long as the US does not stop providing security against our own ports, there will be no difference except that the ports, under control of a reputable business will prosper. It turns out that the royal Arab family that owns this company is very good friends with the Bush family, which would seem, at first, like a political move with Bush not worrying about national security. But consider that the United Arab Emirates is a very good ally with the US. Why would we want to push away our own Arab ally, and why would the United Arab Emirates want to become our enemy? Of course there are probably citizen of the United Arab Emirates that hate the US, but aren't there also US Citizens who would attack the US just as much? By allowing a breach of national security, the United Arab Emirates has more to lose than to gain: strong political ties that bring them huge economic benefits. I propose that the aquasition of these 6 ports is actually a good thing for the US. With such debate over the topic, won't the security at these ports be tighter? Hasn't anyone ever heard the phrase "keep your friends close but your enemies closer"?--not that I think that the United Arab Emirates is our enemy.

But the purchase of US "property" by foreign businesses is nothing new--the Chicago Skyline was recently purchased by a French Company, one who is in negotiations to purchase the Indiana tollway system.

The ports are, essentially, an economic asset. If we were really worried about national security we would focus our attention on the waters right outside the US where a small boat could sail into and, armed with a small but potentially dangerous projectile, could unleash hell onto the large cities on the east and west coasts. There is a bigger threat of that than of a bomb being brought into the US through a port that is monitored by US security.

If anything gets through it will be our own damn faults.

apgovernment said...

Ladies and Gentlemen,
The blog is a forum to discuss controversial topics. Let's remember to NEVER criticize people just ideas. In America we agree to disagree... Let's talk with reason. While I love the passion let's just not get personal.

Anonymous said...

I absolutely agree with Mbrown's statement in that allowing the UAE to control some of our major ports leaves our country susceptible to additional problems of our society's trust in international powers. Although it will probably improve our relations in the middle East, I think we should take baby steps in gaining that relationship. Also, the idea of allowing any foreign country to gain control of OUR ports just creates uneasiness. As we all know, America is pretty much always in a frenzied state, constantly trying to fix problems before it even occurs. I don't think it's necessarily a good idea or a bad idea. The only thing we can do is just let it be, and see what comes of it. Maybe this way, Americans can gain a little trust in the people of the Middle East. We just have to see how things go, we can't automatically assume that things will go wrong and criticize their ability to control our ports simply by race. (ohh yeaaaah, CRASH! Elizabeth)

Anonymous said...

I am very skeptical about the United Arab Emirates control of US ports. These ports are on US soil and should be controlled by the United States to ensure that our country's best interest is always kept in mind. The people Bush is sugesting to run these ports are known as enemies to the American people and a threat to the security of our nation. We already don't trust these people because of terrorism and their control over the oil trade. The money they would be using to by these ports has all come from money that we have put out for oil costs. We should not let people that we don't particularly like and people that are potentially dangerous to our country to run the ports.