Is Fallows too hard on the media? Why or why not...
5 comments:
Anonymous
said...
Fallows isn't even criticizing the media too tough because, well just about everything he said is true. He saw the trustworthy, passionate (what some people think) ABC News reporter Peter Jennings move from a passionate human being who would save American lives in losing his news story to getting persuaded by another reporter, Mike Wallace, to turn a 180 [degrees] and become insensitive by prioritizing his job. Fallows knows the fact that news reporters gain bigger bonuses when they cover larger stories, and at the same time the network receives more money if that story is watched by millions of people. In order for news programs to function, they need money! In order to gain money, the news programs need ratings - so in the process the news programs transformed what they thought was one of their least-watched subject into a series of dramatic relationships...politics. They turned political analysis into a tabloid-style of reporting (think of it as a fusion of National Enquirer and C-SPAN). As commanded to them by their editors, reporters nowadays have to report how a candidate running for an election will win, how a congressman has political differences with his best friend on the opposite political party, and how one political party will dominate the other. Some people may find this interesting because these situations involve conflict. A news program running conflict (no matter what kind of story it is) sparks interest, and interest sparks ratings for the news network, which sparks...(you guessed it)...MONEY! What Fallows notices is missing in this conflict-style of reporting is the most important factor of politics...politics in action. What issues are congressmen dealing with? How will our President change our nation? Even stories currently running about issues (e.g. the Ports controlled by the UAE) have conflict...President Bush vs. the Democrats, Bush vs. his own political party, USA vs. UAE, etc. Turn on the news. You may see a congressman issue a resolution, but what will be emphasized in that news program is who will win in the fight for the ports. Fallows is right about this; he's not making up his facts. I just proved it, and you can believe him and me...just turn on CNN or FOX News during discussions of political analysis. How about The O'Reiley Factor?
I've said it before, and I'll probably say it again, but people really don't see the role of a true journalist as what it should be. I think that what we see in the modern media is a corrupt version of the journalist created by the competition caused by the ever increasing speed of news reporting. Now if a story is not reported right away, somebody else gets the big break. The fact that news networks have become so diverse caused each to adopt some sort of bias so that they would appeal to a consumer group. The result has been a very entertainment biased news media. However The ideal journalist would not be biased at all. This is in fact one of the key elements of true journalism, something that probably no longer exists. A good journalist reports the story as it happens without interfering because any interference will necessarily create a bias and the story will not report the complete truth as it should. Staying unbiased is central to journalism, even if doing so would require great sacrifice, even the death of American soldiers, because that is the only way to report the complete truth.
Now then, you might believe that I am completely making this up, or that it is completely unapplicable to the real world, so after reading this article last semester, I sent an email to British author Karen Traviss about the issue. Having been a journalist and worked in the armed forces, she has an unparalleled view on the role of journalists in such situations, and in her reply told me that whether a journalist should interfere to save lives at the cost of unbiased reporting is one of the most difficult issues even in modern journalism. There really is no clear cut answer. (a little book recommendation: she told me to read her book series, starting with City of Pearl, that features a journalist in a similar situation, and they do give a good perspective on what a journalist should be, and are generally great science fiction novels.)
Try comparing this situation to another that requires impartiality, such as happens in the medical profession. Say that you are testing a new wonder-drug that you're fairly certain would be able to treat cancer. In a normal, however simplified, scientific study half of the test group would receive the drug, and the other half would receive a placebo. The Jennings choice of action in this situation would be to give the drug to both groups, helping more people, but ruining the study. Wallace would do as any good scientist should, he would conduct the study normally, only give the drug to half the people, and see the actual results. Of course, impartiality in journalism is less important (and common) than in medicine, but it is an admirable goal.
Further reasons for the need for journalists to not help American troops would include the fact that the journalists would probably have signed a contract saying that they would not do that in order to work with the Kosanese. Should one violate this trust, not only will they not receive later opportunities to report from behind enemy lines, but it is likely that all the journalists would be imprisoned, or worse.
That said, it's clear that this kind of truly unbiased reporting doesn't really exist anymore. It is an unreachable ideal, and today's journalists should definitely not be judged according to that standard. if they choose to be biased, then they should do what they can to help those that need it. Fallows makes many valid points, but he himself suffers from some bias and fails to completely report the media's side of the arguments.
I think fallows was a little bit hard on the media. By putting jennings and wallace on the spot like he did, they didn't get much chance to think about the whole situation. Plus, it was really a difficult question to answer. On one hand you save the lives of American troops, but it's likely that the otherside could kill you. Although they say their reason for answering what they did is to be a true unbiased journalist, they also could have been thinking about protecting their own life. Besides that, their goal is to give America what it wants to see and to make a whole lot of money.
It seems that Fallows is a little harsh on the media but I have to agree with them. It seems as if the media is just interested in getting the story. Like the reporters were saying they would just stand by and watch while Americans are in danger. I think this says a lot about the media. However they can look at is as they have a job to do, get the story, and thats what they are out there to do.
I think Fallow is exactly right on the fact that media is not very effective and carrying out the real issues to the public. The media is too aware or sensitive of the reaction of the public of their news that they would even take risks of alternating the fact to make it interesting so that people would read their or watch their program more. However, in a way we cannot simply blame the media for their actions because they are doing their best to survive in the media world. there are multiple news stations nowadays that they have to compete amongst each other. In order to survive, each station must try to provide interesting issues or topics in a intersting way that people read their stuff so that they could make a living.
5 comments:
Fallows isn't even criticizing the media too tough because, well just about everything he said is true. He saw the trustworthy, passionate (what some people think) ABC News reporter Peter Jennings move from a passionate human being who would save American lives in losing his news story to getting persuaded by another reporter, Mike Wallace, to turn a 180 [degrees] and become insensitive by prioritizing his job. Fallows knows the fact that news reporters gain bigger bonuses when they cover larger stories, and at the same time the network receives more money if that story is watched by millions of people. In order for news programs to function, they need money! In order to gain money, the news programs need ratings - so in the process the news programs transformed what they thought was one of their least-watched subject into a series of dramatic relationships...politics. They turned political analysis into a tabloid-style of reporting (think of it as a fusion of National Enquirer and C-SPAN). As commanded to them by their editors, reporters nowadays have to report how a candidate running for an election will win, how a congressman has political differences with his best friend on the opposite political party, and how one political party will dominate the other. Some people may find this interesting because these situations involve conflict. A news program running conflict (no matter what kind of story it is) sparks interest, and interest sparks ratings for the news network, which sparks...(you guessed it)...MONEY! What Fallows notices is missing in this conflict-style of reporting is the most important factor of politics...politics in action. What issues are congressmen dealing with? How will our President change our nation? Even stories currently running about issues (e.g. the Ports controlled by the UAE) have conflict...President Bush vs. the Democrats, Bush vs. his own political party, USA vs. UAE, etc. Turn on the news. You may see a congressman issue a resolution, but what will be emphasized in that news program is who will win in the fight for the ports. Fallows is right about this; he's not making up his facts. I just proved it, and you can believe him and me...just turn on CNN or FOX News during discussions of political analysis. How about The O'Reiley Factor?
I've said it before, and I'll probably say it again, but people really don't see the role of a true journalist as what it should be. I think that what we see in the modern media is a corrupt version of the journalist created by the competition caused by the ever increasing speed of news reporting. Now if a story is not reported right away, somebody else gets the big break. The fact that news networks have become so diverse caused each to adopt some sort of bias so that they would appeal to a consumer group. The result has been a very entertainment biased news media. However The ideal journalist would not be biased at all. This is in fact one of the key elements of true journalism, something that probably no longer exists. A good journalist reports the story as it happens without interfering because any interference will necessarily create a bias and the story will not report the complete truth as it should. Staying unbiased is central to journalism, even if doing so would require great sacrifice, even the death of American soldiers, because that is the only way to report the complete truth.
Now then, you might believe that I am completely making this up, or that it is completely unapplicable to the real world, so after reading this article last semester, I sent an email to British author Karen Traviss about the issue. Having been a journalist and worked in the armed forces, she has an unparalleled view on the role of journalists in such situations, and in her reply told me that whether a journalist should interfere to save lives at the cost of unbiased reporting is one of the most difficult issues even in modern journalism. There really is no clear cut answer. (a little book recommendation: she told me to read her book series, starting with City of Pearl, that features a journalist in a similar situation, and they do give a good perspective on what a journalist should be, and are generally great science fiction novels.)
Try comparing this situation to another that requires impartiality, such as happens in the medical profession.
Say that you are testing a new wonder-drug that you're fairly certain would be able to treat cancer. In a normal, however simplified, scientific study half of the test group would receive the drug, and the other half would receive a placebo. The Jennings choice of action in this situation would be to give the drug to both groups, helping more people, but ruining the study. Wallace would do as any good scientist should, he would conduct the study normally, only give the drug to half the people, and see the actual results.
Of course, impartiality in journalism is less important (and common) than in medicine, but it is an admirable goal.
Further reasons for the need for journalists to not help American troops would include the fact that the journalists would probably have signed a contract saying that they would not do that in order to work with the Kosanese. Should one violate this trust, not only will they not receive later opportunities to report from behind enemy lines, but it is likely that all the journalists would be imprisoned, or worse.
That said, it's clear that this kind of truly unbiased reporting doesn't really exist anymore. It is an unreachable ideal, and today's journalists should definitely not be judged according to that standard. if they choose to be biased, then they should do what they can to help those that need it. Fallows makes many valid points, but he himself suffers from some bias and fails to completely report the media's side of the arguments.
I think fallows was a little bit hard on the media. By putting jennings and wallace on the spot like he did, they didn't get much chance to think about the whole situation. Plus, it was really a difficult question to answer. On one hand you save the lives of American troops, but it's likely that the otherside could kill you. Although they say their reason for answering what they did is to be a true unbiased journalist, they also could have been thinking about protecting their own life. Besides that, their goal is to give America what it wants to see and to make a whole lot of money.
It seems that Fallows is a little harsh on the media but I have to agree with them. It seems as if the media is just interested in getting the story. Like the reporters were saying they would just stand by and watch while Americans are in danger. I think this says a lot about the media. However they can look at is as they have a job to do, get the story, and thats what they are out there to do.
I think Fallow is exactly right on the fact that media is not very effective and carrying out the real issues to the public. The media is too aware or sensitive of the reaction of the public of their news that they would even take risks of alternating the fact to make it interesting so that people would read their or watch their program more. However, in a way we cannot simply blame the media for their actions because they are doing their best to survive in the media world. there are multiple news stations nowadays that they have to compete amongst each other. In order to survive, each station must try to provide interesting issues or topics in a intersting way that people read their stuff so that they could make a living.
Post a Comment