Which immigration bill should Congress pass? Should we allow for guest workers? Become tougher on illegal immigrants? Why or why not.
10 comments:
Anonymous
said...
People say that America does not have slavery anymore. I'm not so sure. In a sense, being an illegal alien is very much like being a slave. Employers blackmail illegal aliens into working for below minimum wage or for very hard manuel labor. Our country depends on these workers, sadly enough. They do the jobs that nobody wants to do and keep costs down. Even though the working conditions and pay are probably better in America than in Mexico ( I say Mexico because it is by far the largest source of illegal immigrants), it still means that they are unlicensed as a driver. One in twenty illegal immagrants will kill someone while driving (according to a recent study by the AAA). We need a good border patrol to keep the numbers down, yet we survive on people constantly afraid of being caught, therefore, taking menial jobs for low pay.
I think that all illegal immigrants should be able to obtain "permanent resident" status, and they should be given a reasonable time limit for that status to remain under their name. During this time limit they should be forced to apply for citizenship. If they do not, there should be some sort of pentaly. My mom and I have gone through the whole process of becoming citizens, and we'll both tell you that it's not an easy one but is necessary. I don't think it's right for immigrants to come to America in search of freedom and a new life and not even apply for citizenship in this country. Illigal immigration laws should become more stricter so everything is kept fair for those who are current citizens.
I agree that although they are illegal immigrants, they are helping our country and giving back to it. We should allow them the opportunity to become citizens. It is true that most illegal immigrants are hard working and fulfilling jobs that many Americans wouldn’t want to do. It is also important that we do control the amount of illegal immigrants because we don’t want it becoming overflowing. Also we don’t want illegal immigrants to be taking away job opportunities from American citizens but as it is seen now there is enough opportunity for everyone so we should allow every the chance to pursue it, because that is what America is all about. However, Illegal immigrant laws should be strict to some extent to keep it fair for hard working American citizens. I feel that it is a very tough issue to decide on
The problem is that many of the illegal aliens have created a life in America,but the idea of just letting them suddenly become citizens doesn't address the fact that they have done something ILLEGAL! This isn't saying that we should disregard the fact that they are a contributing members of society and take jobs Americans do not want. The idea of a green card, for those who want to work, is a good idea because people have greater opportunities here, that's why our ancestors immigrated here hundreds of years ago, and we should allow others to be involved too. But we have to remember that it was in fact hundreds of years ago and our population has increased and terrorism is a problem, we have to be more careful with who we allow into the country. Laws for immigration should be stricter because we can't afford another 9/11. And if someone really has a passion to live in America they should respect our system and come in legally.
I think immigration laws should definitely be harsher. Although the illegal aliens make up a good portion of the labor force, they are taking jobs that actual citizens should have. They don't have a legal or moral right to those jobs and shouldn't be allowed to have them. Besides that, being an illegal immigrant means they have broken the law and should be punished for it. If they are disatisfied with the little freedom they have in their country, they should join together and do something about it rather than look to the U.S. for help. Although this may seem tough to do, its obvious that there's enough people who try to illegal immigrate that could make an impact in their own country. Rather than try to sneak into the U.S. through the back door, they should try to do it legally. This way at least, the U.S. government can regulate how many come into the country. I find it ridiculous that someone who is illegally living in the U.S. can attend school here and take someone else's place in a college because they're a minority. They shouldn't even be in the country in the first place.
Because I am an immigrant myself, I am more aware of issues regarding immigration. I definitely agree with Alexandra that it is extremely complicated process becoming a citizen. My family is in process of getting green card and it has driven my dad crazy because it is so much work and very stressful even though we are legal immigrants. So I feel the pain for illegal immigrants who basically have no rights. When I read in the newspaper that immigrant workers got fired because they were marching in Chicago, I felt even worse.I do not think that the illegal immigrants are taking citizens' jobs away because these are unpleasant, hard labor jobs that no one would take for little money. I do understand that the US government need to regulate the matter because it is just not possible to accept everyone into the US. However, some illegal immigrants have legitimate reasons why they fled, etc. and their intentions are not harmful. For those individuals, at least basic human rights should be allowed.
I think that the laws on illegal immigrants should be much harder. Even though the illegal immigrants take a lot of jobs in the work force, they don't belong in our country if they are breaking laws and they are doing that by being here without being citizens. Also, these people are getting many benefits and things paid for them, with our money because we are citizens and they aren't. I think if we could make it easier to become a citizen that would be more beneficial to our country because the immigrants would know the laws and be forced to pay taxes and things like that also. I also think we need more programs for people to learn to speak english, because its ridiculous to have people come and live here and never learn english.
Immigration issue, i think , is one of the most sensative issues in the US. United States is standing on the principle that it is a free country. With that name earned, it is tough for the US to block the immigrants. However, letting in all the immigrants who comes to United States is not safe and too messy. So United States nowadays have strict laws and processes that an immigrant must go throught in order to become a legal residents of the United States. However these processes are long and exhausting. As an immigrant myself, i had to wait about 5 years to obtain a greencard and Now that i am approved as a legal resident of the united states, i have to wait another 5 or 6 years to become a citizen of the united states. The documents that they receive in the immigration center never gets opened for a long time and they are very slow at making decisions. There are definatley things that could be changed to make the immigration process more efficient, i believe.
the argument isn't about whether the illegal immigrants are hardworking, people with good intentions. and yes, they have helped our country to a certain degree. But a law is a law, and they are still immmigrating illegally. Laws are meant to be followed.
Time for a little bit of perspective: we're all immigrants.
With that said, the idea of senators sitting on Capitol Hill and deciding who stays and who goes, or rather who stays and who stays illegally, is preposterous. Unless they're Native Americans, they have no legitimacy in dictating "who is American". Imagine; the 6th generation immigrant turning his back on the 1st generation immigrant. It's as ironic as it is sad.
10 comments:
People say that America does not have slavery anymore. I'm not so sure. In a sense, being an illegal alien is very much like being a slave. Employers blackmail illegal aliens into working for below minimum wage or for very hard manuel labor. Our country depends on these workers, sadly enough. They do the jobs that nobody wants to do and keep costs down. Even though the working conditions and pay are probably better in America than in Mexico ( I say Mexico because it is by far the largest source of illegal immigrants), it still means that they are unlicensed as a driver. One in twenty illegal immagrants will kill someone while driving (according to a recent study by the AAA). We need a good border patrol to keep the numbers down, yet we survive on people constantly afraid of being caught, therefore, taking menial jobs for low pay.
I think that all illegal immigrants should be able to obtain "permanent resident" status, and they should be given a reasonable time limit for that status to remain under their name. During this time limit they should be forced to apply for citizenship. If they do not, there should be some sort of pentaly. My mom and I have gone through the whole process of becoming citizens, and we'll both tell you that it's not an easy one but is necessary. I don't think it's right for immigrants to come to America in search of freedom and a new life and not even apply for citizenship in this country. Illigal immigration laws should become more stricter so everything is kept fair for those who are current citizens.
I agree that although they are illegal immigrants, they are helping our country and giving back to it. We should allow them the opportunity to become citizens. It is true that most illegal immigrants are hard working and fulfilling jobs that many Americans wouldn’t want to do. It is also important that we do control the amount of illegal immigrants because we don’t want it becoming overflowing. Also we don’t want illegal immigrants to be taking away job opportunities from American citizens but as it is seen now there is enough opportunity for everyone so we should allow every the chance to pursue it, because that is what America is all about. However, Illegal immigrant laws should be strict to some extent to keep it fair for hard working American citizens. I feel that it is a very tough issue to decide on
The problem is that many of the illegal aliens have created a life in America,but the idea of just letting them suddenly become citizens doesn't address the fact that they have done something ILLEGAL! This isn't saying that we should disregard the fact that they are a contributing members of society and take jobs Americans do not want. The idea of a green card, for those who want to work, is a good idea because people have greater opportunities here, that's why our ancestors immigrated here hundreds of years ago, and we should allow others to be involved too. But we have to remember that it was in fact hundreds of years ago and our population has increased and terrorism is a problem, we have to be more careful with who we allow into the country. Laws for immigration should be stricter because we can't afford another 9/11. And if someone really has a passion to live in America they should respect our system and come in legally.
I think immigration laws should definitely be harsher. Although the illegal aliens make up a good portion of the labor force, they are taking jobs that actual citizens should have. They don't have a legal or moral right to those jobs and shouldn't be allowed to have them. Besides that, being an illegal immigrant means they have broken the law and should be punished for it. If they are disatisfied with the little freedom they have in their country, they should join together and do something about it rather than look to the U.S. for help. Although this may seem tough to do, its obvious that there's enough people who try to illegal immigrate that could make an impact in their own country. Rather than try to sneak into the U.S. through the back door, they should try to do it legally. This way at least, the U.S. government can regulate how many come into the country. I find it ridiculous that someone who is illegally living in the U.S. can attend school here and take someone else's place in a college because they're a minority. They shouldn't even be in the country in the first place.
Because I am an immigrant myself, I am more aware of issues regarding immigration. I definitely agree with Alexandra that it is extremely complicated process becoming a citizen. My family is in process of getting green card and it has driven my dad crazy because it is so much work and very stressful even though we are legal immigrants. So I feel the pain for illegal immigrants who basically have no rights. When I read in the newspaper that immigrant workers got fired because they were marching in Chicago, I felt even worse.I do not think that the illegal immigrants are taking citizens' jobs away because these are unpleasant, hard labor jobs that no one would take for little money. I do understand that the US government need to regulate the matter because it is just not possible to accept everyone into the US. However, some illegal immigrants have legitimate reasons why they fled, etc. and their intentions are not harmful. For those individuals, at least basic human rights should be allowed.
I think that the laws on illegal immigrants should be much harder. Even though the illegal immigrants take a lot of jobs in the work force, they don't belong in our country if they are breaking laws and they are doing that by being here without being citizens. Also, these people are getting many benefits and things paid for them, with our money because we are citizens and they aren't. I think if we could make it easier to become a citizen that would be more beneficial to our country because the immigrants would know the laws and be forced to pay taxes and things like that also. I also think we need more programs for people to learn to speak english, because its ridiculous to have people come and live here and never learn english.
Immigration issue, i think , is one of the most sensative issues in the US. United States is standing on the principle that it is a free country. With that name earned, it is tough for the US to block the immigrants. However, letting in all the immigrants who comes to United States is not safe and too messy. So United States nowadays have strict laws and processes that an immigrant must go throught in order to become a legal residents of the United States. However these processes are long and exhausting. As an immigrant myself, i had to wait about 5 years to obtain a greencard and Now that i am approved as a legal resident of the united states, i have to wait another 5 or 6 years to become a citizen of the united states. The documents that they receive in the immigration center never gets opened for a long time and they are very slow at making decisions. There are definatley things that could be changed to make the immigration process more efficient, i believe.
the argument isn't about whether the illegal immigrants are hardworking, people with good intentions. and yes, they have helped our country to a certain degree. But a law is a law, and they are still immmigrating illegally. Laws are meant to be followed.
Time for a little bit of perspective: we're all immigrants.
With that said, the idea of senators sitting on Capitol Hill and deciding who stays and who goes, or rather who stays and who stays illegally, is preposterous. Unless they're Native Americans, they have no legitimacy in dictating "who is American". Imagine; the 6th generation immigrant turning his back on the 1st generation immigrant. It's as ironic as it is sad.
Post a Comment