Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Friday, August 25, 2006

Cease Fire In Mid East

Will the current cease fire between Israel and Lebanon last? Or will fighting between these two countries erupt again? Why or why not...

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

I really don't think that the cease fire will last long at all. Once the UN has gone through with their plan of action and Southern Lebanon is back in the hands of the Lebanese government, Hezbollah will only have more freedom to take charge once more. Fanatics like Hezbollah never give up. They have so much influence over the the Lebanese people and government. Israel's hope to disarm them by invading Lebanon will be crushed once Hezzbollah has the freedom to walk all over the Lebanese governement and political spectrum. It will only go back to the way it was.

Anonymous said...

The ceasefire won't last because it fails to adress the problem. The conflict between Israel and Lebanon is only a microsm of the larger conflict between the Palestinian people, who inhabited the land pre-1948, and the Israelis, who were given the land by the British in 1948. Both sides of the conflict have reasonable positions. The best compromise is a two-state solution, with Jerusalem, the true meat of the issue, becoming an international, UN-operated city, literally the capitl of the world. An Israeli massacre of Hezbollah, or the other way around, is not a fair conclusion to this debate.

Anonymous said...

I know your new last name!! Science teacher Mr. Mark (last name censored) told me..

Anonymous said...

j-rod, a couple of corrections-
While yes, it is probably true that Iran has some involvement with Hezbollah, it makes no political sense for Iran to want America out. First of all, Shi'a is the minority sect throughout the Arab world, except for Iraq. Iran, which is Persian, also happens to be dominated by Shi'as. If the US leaves, the Sunni-Shi'a conflict tthere will turn into a full blwn civil war, with Saudi Arabia and the rest of the Arab world on the side of the Sunni minority in Iraq. Iran does not want a conflict of that nature, especially because the US would side with Saudi Arabia, thus isolating Iran from the entre Western world and its vast stock of tradable military supplies. on the other hand, if the US stays, we will install a democracy that will inevitably be controlled be the 75% Shi'a majority that was held down so long under the Sunni Ba'athist regime of Saddam Hussein. Also, foreign insurgents make up only a small fraction of insurgents in Iraq. The largest insurgent group is that commanded by Shi'a cleric Muqtad al-Sadr, an Iraqi native. In response to your claim that Saddam Hussein was our greatest ally in the region: first of all, strictly speaking, that distinction belongs to Israel. Second- Saddam Hussein was our ally in the early 1980's. This made sense. He was at war with a country that had taken American hostages (Iran), so we gave him chemical and biological weapons to use on Iran. We sold Iran a vast amount of weapons, but that was so we could finance terrorists in Nicaragua. Different story. Anyways, the chemical weapons we gave to Saddam went not against Iran, but against Kurds in Northern Iraq. A truly fine use of American WMD's. Then Saddam invaded Kuwait, a US-friendly oil producer, and we threw him out in Desert Storm. After that, Iraq was placed under tough economic and military sanctions. His nuclear and biological weapons programs were uncovered and shut down in 1998, leaving the full Iraqi military might of the Republican Guard, a meager force if ever there was. The main forces containing Iranian aggression are Saudi Arabia and the US troops that have been stationed there for the past decade. The best way to stop all of this Middle East mess is to back in time to 1922 and kill a British civil servant by the name of Matthew Sykes. Look him up. He's incredibly interesting.

Anonymous said...

I think that there will always be conflict in/with/around Isreal. The land on which Isreal rests is way to important to way to many people. The fighting over it will never stop. p.s this is jon keenan btw

Anonymous said...

The current ceasefire will certainly not last. While the Israeli government expects a windfall of politcal unrest in response to wide allegations of insufficient troop training/support and uninformed decisions to execute a costly ground offensive, the meanignful political complex of the region--whether or not Palestinians should pursue EITHER the 'Right of Return' or an autonomous state--is forgotten.
Even more, the UN's continued inability to ENFORCE its own agenda--the multi-nation security force dispatched to the region still has doubts about rules of engagement with Hezbellah fighters--simply reinforces a pervading nation in Israel, America and even Iran: the UN only knows two verbs...to meet and to issue resolutions.
All other abilities beyond conferences and useless mandates/resolutions/sanctions are lost amidst diplomatic appeasement to the Third World and a subtle disposition to a Democrat bastion defending herself against incessant attack: Israel.

Anonymous said...

One thing that confuses me is that people seem to be coming down squarely on Israel's side. While yes, the countries that support Hezbollah do so for malicious reasons, the idea of Palestinians taking back their homeland has as much merit as Israel's sovreignty. Remember, these people had their land swiped from them by a European power (Britain) and handed to another ethnic group. Hezbollah may be considered terrorists, but so were the Contras, which had American support. Oh, there was another group fighting guerilla war for their freedom. It was a long time ago. They were called...Minutemen? I think that was it.

kgluskin said...

I hope this ceasefire lasts, but there is so much tension between the two countries I don't know if it can. Israel has had rocky relations with the middle east its entire existence, and no matter what it does, these relations don't improve. It's not fair to force Israel to agree to all treaties and give up all its rights, but it's also not fair for the violence to continue and innocent people be killed, which is why this is such a pressing issue. Both countries need to be willing to give a little, without losing its principles, to maintain peace in the middle east.

Anonymous said...

In response to a rather cursory Middle Eastern history harangue from dabrownsensation, Hezbollah is not following any distorted UN rationalization of national defense, given that Hezbollah's Islamic STATE is not an internationally recognized entity, nor did the POLITICAL ORGANIZATION--indeed, this is also not a legitimate country--respect the UN approved border when it captured murdered 7 and captured 2 Israeli soldiers.
Indeed, the fundamental breech of any reasonable calculation for war, including the Augustinian 'Just War Theory'--something I do hope dabrownsensation does recall from World History--that occurred when Hezbollah attacked autonomous Israeli soil was overtly disregarded in international press.
Perhaps dabrownsensation's bellicose theory that "innocent children are always murdered by Israel on a daily basis" is right: a nation that has ALWAYS given back contested territory gained from an Arabian-initiated war (1948, 1967, 1973 and the recent conflict)and even labors to remove Palestinians from refugee camps into federally-constructed houses--refer to summer publication of 'Campus Watch'--simply cannot defend herself from an act of war even William Jennings Bryan would contest.
I fear that debrownsansation reflects an insidious example of how little the international electorate and media care for what is often a neglected cycle of bigotry. A seething instance last occurred (aside from the post to which I am responding) in 2000, when Arafat, assembled at Camp David with Clinton and Ehud Barak, declined an offer of 98% of the land he desired. He then went to war against the Iranian-titled Zionist Empire.
If bigotry is indeed the precipitant of the New World Order, then dabrownsensation subscribes to a growing international convention of ignorance and romantic fanaticism with an extremist 'underdog': Hezbollah.

Anonymous said...

I think it is fairly irrelevant if the cease-fire lasts; I think any amount of time spent not killing each other is a good thing. My head was shaking when we sent in Condi to counter the peace process. It's almost as though the powers at be would prefer a world with hot wars rather than icy peace.

Then again, this is all set against the backdrop in Iraq. Over the past week, 100 Iraqis have been found dead in Bagdhad, executed and tortured.