Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Police of the World

Should the US be the policemen of the World?? Do they have a moral duty to step into countries where ethnic minorities are being slaughtered? Why or why not...

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

In my opinion, the US should go into countries that are in desperate need. For example, there is a huge genocide in Sudan, and we have the power to stop it, but we are not. I think one of the reasons people think we shouldnt act as a police force is because we think that every country can protect itself. However, every minority group cannot fight the groups that are opressing it, and it is our job to help them out. Americans do not know the extent that the groups are desperate for outside help, and that is why we dont want to get involved. However, genocides will not be stopped unless someone steps in, and we have the power to do it.

Anonymous said...

the US should not police the world... but i do believe that if there are places that are having mass genocide that we should step in and try to help, not necessarily militarily but political also.

Anonymous said...

If the US were to, all of a sudden, start to become the policemen of the world, then I would say the US does not have a moral duty to step into countries where ethnic minorities are being slaughtered. However, from the point our Founding Fathers have created United States of America, the US were involved in and were the leaders of much of international events. Since then US's responsibility have grown so much in the world that they need to stay and act as the policemen of the world. So many of the countries look to US for their help and aid and sometimes even for punishments. For example, a group of Korean missionaries were captured by the Talibans this past summer and the Korean government had limited power to do anything about it. They, almost reflexively, turned to the US for their aid- although the captives were soon freed before the US intervened. US holds great amount of power in the world, and if it wasnt the US, who would be the world's policemen? :p

Abby said...

In my opinion, I do not think the US should police the world using the military, unless (as others said) there is an immense amount of genocide like in Sudan. Sometimes I think that unless a country asks, we should let them be; they are able to take care of themselves, and though me may feel compelled to help, we shouldn't force our opinions of how their culture should be on them.

Dan - 4 said...

I think that since around 1900, America has been propelled into international politics, which is an extreme benefit to keeping the US from being isolated from the rest of the world because most of the rest of the world already dislikes America. However, I believe that it is not the duty of the US to play policeman for the world, except for giving aid in times of 'world war' or stepping in when they are directly affected. Although I agree that it isn't fair that the world allows events such as genocide to occur, the US should instead of diving in, use what power they have in the United Nations to attempt to rally support. The United Nations has become almost completely worthless, however, therefore there is a small capacity of reliance on them. Thus, until the United Nations shows that it is capable of policing the world, since that is its main purpose as an establishment, that the United States should stay in favor of the rest of the world by being extremely selective in the fights it picks.

Nelly-5 said...

I think the U.S. should only intervene if it completely necessary. If it is something as big as a genocide, then U.S. should definately intervene. On the other hand, if it is a matter of political conflict within the country, then U.S. should try and stay out unless mass numbers of people are being murdered. Troops should only be sent as a very last resort if no other possibility exists. The U.S. should not be the police of the world becuase that implies involvement in every issue no matter the size.

Brandon Silver said...

Just because we are a superpower does not mean that the world belongs to us. There are hundreds of countries that make up the world, and everyone should pitch in for ultimate safety. Unfortunately, there are some places which could require intervention, but if it's not 100% necessary there is no reason we need to become involved.

Anonymous said...

The bottom line is, the US has a responsibility that comes along with its immense wealth and prosperity. To not use it is to be irresponsible and negligent. I understand people want to stick to themselves and do want to involve themselves in other countries "Business." If thats how you truly want it, stop trading with other countries, importing their goods, and using their cheap labor. The world is smaller than it used to be, and we as Americans cant just pick and choose where to become involved.

Mallory Rubin said...

I agree with Ali Fields' comment. With globalization, all countries have become intertwined economically or politically. Staying isolationist is impossible in today's society. Since the US is a major world power, it has the obligation to intervene if there are problems in other countries. Even if there is no apparent need to intervene, chaos across the seas still affects the US.

Anonymous said...

The U.S. is one of the most powerful nations in the world. As we've heard from the great Spiderman himself, "with great power comes great responsibility." I think that it is important for America to use its wealth and power to positively influence countries in need. I feel that the U.S. should make agreements with the country first before they start interferring on their ways. There are always exceptions, of course, especially when there is a ruler who is bringing the nation down to nothing. In instances like this, I think that even though it doesn't seem like it's our business, we need to step in to help. If the U.S., being such a powerful nation doesn't step in and help, who will?

Monica W. p.4