The Illinois General Assembly overrode Gov. Blag's veto and immediately required schools to begin the school day with a moment of silence. What are your opinions of this new mandate? How will it affects schools? How will it affect students?
I think it's good for discussion (possibly the opposite of this bill's intentions) and argument of the whole religion and school issue.
The fact it was passed says something about how Illinois isn't just home to a liberal metropolitan population, yet downstate we've got religious citizens and they're represented.
Also, this entire bill is stupid in terms of punishment if schools don't participate, there is no penalty. It's stupid and perhaps a waste of time. I now see a clear reason why there was a delay in the budget this year, the Illinois congress was more interested in "important manners."
With the way the bill is being implemented right now, especially at Stevenson, it serves absolutely no purpose. The 7 seconds given for silence is not nearly enough time to "make reflections", making one of the best(<-sarcasm) reasons to pass this bill pointless. We've seen how the school handles this; Gonzalez and probably the majority of the staff don't take it seriously, so what reason do we have to? This leaves the students falling into two groups, those who are opposed to the new law, and those who just don't care. I don't see the purpose of government if all they're doing is passing yet another law that doesn't benefit anyone, save maybe one Protestant that has a 7 second prayer ready, leaving the rest of us to just ignore it.
However..I also feel that students are making an overly big deal about this, claiming that it violates their rights, and tarnishes the constitution. The law doesn't harm anyone or create any incredible inconveniences in our lives, so getting worked up over it doesn't seem that reasonable. But whatever, whether it be the young voice or the gears beginning to turn in the dusty heads of the state legislature, I don't see this law lasting very long.
Personally, i think the law would be a bit more beneficial at Stevenson if it was more than 10 seconds long. We actually times it in my first hour class and the longest one so far was barely 20 secinds long. That isn't even enough time to remember what you had for breakfaast. Even so, many teachers don't even require theis student to be silent. My class actually missed it completely because people were coming in late and we just did not notice it. I think that people are making too big of a deal out of it. Taking 20 seconds out of first period will not cause the entire day to go wrong, so people just need to calm down.
I agree with Dan the moment of silence in Stevenson is barely 10 seconds long and it seems way too forced. Personally in my first period class everyone just talks through it thinking its a joke. Jeff G
Erik Halverson 5 I think this bill is one of the best things to come out of the Illinois Legislature. For the first time in a long time, the government is directly affecting us, and we are angry about it. Personally i think the bill is a joke, and the fact that we pay people to argue about passing manditory silence in schools, is very disapointing. But the fact that so many kids are now affected by it, they are looking into it, learning about it, discussing it and getting involved. The fact that students claim in infringes upon their rights, well, thats up the a personal opinion of "rights", but it doesnt say you have to pray, so it doesnt infringe on school prayer.
But a big thank you to our congressmen and women for getting us off of our "doesnt affect me" mentality and involved. Through this, I believe we have ,mrs lal, raised our politcal efficacy.
First of all, I dont believe the Moment of Silence was supposed to do anything with religion from the start so I can not say it violates our freedom of religion rights. It was only implemented so that the students can have time to "reflect" so in a way I believe it is something we can truly benefit from. It gives us time to actually keep "7 seconds" of our lives in peace and think- however, it is so unrealistic in action because no one is quiet during the Moment of Silence, too busy finishing up their homework or talking with friends. The Illinois government should have thought it through more before passing it as a mandate. It should have required homes or a smaller public groups to do moment of silence rather than the big public schools.
I think that the bill serves no purpose because if all the schools are enforcing it the way Stevenson does then it is pointless. No one really acknowledges that we are suppose to be quiet, and the amount of time is so short I don't think anyone would beable to get a meaningful thought in.
In my opinion, this bill will not last long because too many students disagree with it, and that is who it's regarding. Also, it's very difficult to enforce, because there is no way to make sure that people abide the rule of no talking during the moment. Also, no one takes this law seriously! we have gone through 12 years of schooling, and no one is about to change just because of the new moment of silence. On the other hand, the moment of silence doesn't do any harm. I dont think it's long enough to be effective, but if it were, it wouldn't be a bad thing if everyone thought about their day for 30 seconds or so. The law is not bad, it could even be beneficial to relax in the morning, its just that people dont take it seriously, so it will never work
personally, I think that the moment of silence is pointless. It lasts for what seems to be about ten seconds, and no one takes it seriously. I don't mind the moment of silence for that reason, but I do believe it is unnecessary. You can barely even finish a thought in the time given. If a law is going to be passed that's meant to give you time to reflect, it only makes sense to give an appropriate amount of time to actually do so. However, I don't exactly understand why some are so against it, and argue its unconstitutionality. Maybe if the moment of silence was... I don't know... at LEAST a minute, I would understand their frustration. JennaW
Because this bill is so loosely enforced, i really don't see an issue with it. Although I don't think its 100% necessary, I don't think that is offensive to anyone in any way. Many students argue that it defies separation between church and state; however, its merely just a time for reflection. Its not mandatory to participate in and theres no scrolling prayer on prompters that you are forced or encouraged to read silently, its merely a small, minuscule fragment in time devoted to individual thought.
I greatly dislike the required moment of silence at the beginning of the school day. I understand that the silence does not require students to pray; it is only meant as a time to reflect. But I attend a public, secular school. If I wanted to pray or reflect in school, I would attend a religious school. I believe that this is the first step for legislation to promote prayer in schools.
Plus, the short amount of time alloted for prayer reduces the requirement to a joke. Even if I wanted to utilize the moment of silence, how much would I actually be able to think about in the given 10 seconds?
The government should not be telling me when I should reflect on my day. Why should they decide that for me? If I wanted to pray or reflect I could do it on my own time, not in a school environment.
In my opinion, I think that the moment of silence is pointless. From what i have seen these couple of past weeks, nobody really follows it, and it doesn't really bring any good use. First of all, the moment of silence isn't even a minute, so how are kids supposed to bring their thoughts together in about ten seconds? Nobody really takes it seriously; it seems like some teacher don't even seem to care very much. i also dont think its fair for a student to not want to participate in the moment of silence. Stasey G p 4
The moment of silence allows me to reflect, if only for a brief time, on the morning I have had. I can think about how long I brushed my teeth for, how much sleep I didn't get, and I can stress a little more about the test later that day. Therefore, I think the moment of silence is one of the most significant bills that has passed as long as I have been living...NOT! I proudly applaud the congressmen who spent their time passing this bill rather than simply pushing some funds around to support the flood control plans for the Des Plaines River, which have already been designed. The government seems to really be on par with the people's needs.
I think this moment of silence is worthless. There it is not being enforced at all and no penalty for it. Also, Stevenson barely even has a moment of silence. I believe it should be a lot longer than a few seconds. It should maybe be a few minutes. If it is really intended to be a period of reflection...there isn't much you can reflect over in just a few seconds. I don't think we should even do it anymore. Our congress wastes their time and stupid bills like these that don't effect anyone really. I don't think anyone really pays attention to the "moment of silence."
I don't think people should get so worked up about the moment of silence. It has nothing to do with religion, it's just some time to think. If you don't like it, just close your eyes and chill out, there's better things to get mad about.
I think the moment of silence is pointless. I think this law should not have been enforced because it is too hard to regulate and most people don't even use this time to reflect because many students are still coming into class or are talking through it. Because many students as well as faculty are either opposed to it or just don't care, it is not taken seriously as many would have wanted it to, and therefore is pointless. Alexa C.
Personally, I find nothing wrong with having a moment of silence at the beginning of the day. My old school in Georgia used to make us say the pledge and have a moment of silence everyday before school started. So actually to me, not having a moment of silence when i moved here seemed wierd. I don't think having this new mandate will affect schools or students because the moment of silence is such a short period of time. I also think the moment of silence should be optional for everyone because if someone doesn't believe in it then they should not be forced to participate, just like you don't have to say the pledge anymore.
17 comments:
I think it's good for discussion (possibly the opposite of this bill's intentions) and argument of the whole religion and school issue.
The fact it was passed says something about how Illinois isn't just home to a liberal metropolitan population, yet downstate we've got religious citizens and they're represented.
Also, this entire bill is stupid in terms of punishment if schools don't participate, there is no penalty. It's stupid and perhaps a waste of time. I now see a clear reason why there was a delay in the budget this year, the Illinois congress was more interested in "important manners."
With the way the bill is being implemented right now, especially at Stevenson, it serves absolutely no purpose. The 7 seconds given for silence is not nearly enough time to "make reflections", making one of the best(<-sarcasm) reasons to pass this bill pointless. We've seen how the school handles this; Gonzalez and probably the majority of the staff don't take it seriously, so what reason do we have to? This leaves the students falling into two groups, those who are opposed to the new law, and those who just don't care. I don't see the purpose of government if all they're doing is passing yet another law that doesn't benefit anyone, save maybe one Protestant that has a 7 second prayer ready, leaving the rest of us to just ignore it.
However..I also feel that students are making an overly big deal about this, claiming that it violates their rights, and tarnishes the constitution. The law doesn't harm anyone or create any incredible inconveniences in our lives, so getting worked up over it doesn't seem that reasonable. But whatever, whether it be the young voice or the gears beginning to turn in the dusty heads of the state legislature, I don't see this law lasting very long.
Personally, i think the law would be a bit more beneficial at Stevenson if it was more than 10 seconds long. We actually times it in my first hour class and the longest one so far was barely 20 secinds long. That isn't even enough time to remember what you had for breakfaast. Even so, many teachers don't even require theis student to be silent. My class actually missed it completely because people were coming in late and we just did not notice it. I think that people are making too big of a deal out of it. Taking 20 seconds out of first period will not cause the entire day to go wrong, so people just need to calm down.
I agree with Dan the moment of silence in Stevenson is barely 10 seconds long and it seems way too forced. Personally in my first period class everyone just talks through it thinking its a joke.
Jeff G
Erik Halverson 5
I think this bill is one of the best things to come out of the Illinois Legislature. For the first time in a long time, the government is directly affecting us, and we are angry about it. Personally i think the bill is a joke, and the fact that we pay people to argue about passing manditory silence in schools, is very disapointing. But the fact that so many kids are now affected by it, they are looking into it, learning about it, discussing it and getting involved. The fact that students claim in infringes upon their rights, well, thats up the a personal opinion of "rights", but it doesnt say you have to pray, so it doesnt infringe on school prayer.
But a big thank you to our congressmen and women for getting us off of our "doesnt affect me" mentality and involved. Through this, I believe we have ,mrs lal, raised our politcal efficacy.
First of all, I dont believe the Moment of Silence was supposed to do anything with religion from the start so I can not say it violates our freedom of religion rights. It was only implemented so that the students can have time to "reflect" so in a way I believe it is something we can truly benefit from. It gives us time to actually keep "7 seconds" of our lives in peace and think- however, it is so unrealistic in action because no one is quiet during the Moment of Silence, too busy finishing up their homework or talking with friends. The Illinois government should have thought it through more before passing it as a mandate. It should have required homes or a smaller public groups to do moment of silence rather than the big public schools.
I think that the bill serves no purpose because if all the schools are enforcing it the way Stevenson does then it is pointless. No one really acknowledges that we are suppose to be quiet, and the amount of time is so short I don't think anyone would beable to get a meaningful thought in.
In my opinion, this bill will not last long because too many students disagree with it, and that is who it's regarding. Also, it's very difficult to enforce, because there is no way to make sure that people abide the rule of no talking during the moment. Also, no one takes this law seriously! we have gone through 12 years of schooling, and no one is about to change just because of the new moment of silence.
On the other hand, the moment of silence doesn't do any harm. I dont think it's long enough to be effective, but if it were, it wouldn't be a bad thing if everyone thought about their day for 30 seconds or so. The law is not bad, it could even be beneficial to relax in the morning, its just that people dont take it seriously, so it will never work
personally, I think that the moment of silence is pointless. It lasts for what seems to be about ten seconds, and no one takes it seriously. I don't mind the moment of silence for that reason, but I do believe it is unnecessary. You can barely even finish a thought in the time given. If a law is going to be passed that's meant to give you time to reflect, it only makes sense to give an appropriate amount of time to actually do so. However, I don't exactly understand why some are so against it, and argue its unconstitutionality. Maybe if the moment of silence was... I don't know... at LEAST a minute, I would understand their frustration.
JennaW
Because this bill is so loosely enforced, i really don't see an issue with it. Although I don't think its 100% necessary, I don't think that is offensive to anyone in any way. Many students argue that it defies separation between church and state; however, its merely just a time for reflection. Its not mandatory to participate in and theres no scrolling prayer on prompters that you are forced or encouraged to read silently, its merely a small, minuscule fragment in time devoted to individual thought.
Ari - 4
I greatly dislike the required moment of silence at the beginning of the school day. I understand that the silence does not require students to pray; it is only meant as a time to reflect. But I attend a public, secular school. If I wanted to pray or reflect in school, I would attend a religious school. I believe that this is the first step for legislation to promote prayer in schools.
Plus, the short amount of time alloted for prayer reduces the requirement to a joke. Even if I wanted to utilize the moment of silence, how much would I actually be able to think about in the given 10 seconds?
The government should not be telling me when I should reflect on my day. Why should they decide that for me? If I wanted to pray or reflect I could do it on my own time, not in a school environment.
In my opinion, I think that the moment of silence is pointless. From what i have seen these couple of past weeks, nobody really follows it, and it doesn't really bring any good use. First of all, the moment of silence isn't even a minute, so how are kids supposed to bring their thoughts together in about ten seconds? Nobody really takes it seriously; it seems like some teacher don't even seem to care very much. i also dont think its fair for a student to not want to participate in the moment of silence.
Stasey G p 4
The moment of silence allows me to reflect, if only for a brief time, on the morning I have had. I can think about how long I brushed my teeth for, how much sleep I didn't get, and I can stress a little more about the test later that day. Therefore, I think the moment of silence is one of the most significant bills that has passed as long as I have been living...NOT! I proudly applaud the congressmen who spent their time passing this bill rather than simply pushing some funds around to support the flood control plans for the Des Plaines River, which have already been designed. The government seems to really be on par with the people's needs.
I think this moment of silence is worthless. There it is not being enforced at all and no penalty for it. Also, Stevenson barely even has a moment of silence. I believe it should be a lot longer than a few seconds. It should maybe be a few minutes. If it is really intended to be a period of reflection...there isn't much you can reflect over in just a few seconds. I don't think we should even do it anymore. Our congress wastes their time and stupid bills like these that don't effect anyone really. I don't think anyone really pays attention to the "moment of silence."
I don't think people should get so worked up about the moment of silence. It has nothing to do with religion, it's just some time to think. If you don't like it, just close your eyes and chill out, there's better things to get mad about.
I think the moment of silence is pointless. I think this law should not have been enforced because it is too hard to regulate and most people don't even use this time to reflect because many students are still coming into class or are talking through it. Because many students as well as faculty are either opposed to it or just don't care, it is not taken seriously as many would have wanted it to, and therefore is pointless.
Alexa C.
Personally, I find nothing wrong with having a moment of silence at the beginning of the day. My old school in Georgia used to make us say the pledge and have a moment of silence everyday before school started. So actually to me, not having a moment of silence when i moved here seemed wierd. I don't think having this new mandate will affect schools or students because the moment of silence is such a short period of time. I also think the moment of silence should be optional for everyone because if someone doesn't believe in it then they should not be forced to participate, just like you don't have to say the pledge anymore.
Post a Comment