Should the US use whatever tactics necessary to extract information from suspects of terrorist activities? Can the gov't use whatever means to obtain intelligence from those who know? What defines torture? What means must the gov't employ when combating terrorism???
10 comments:
I believe that US should use whatever tactics necessary to extract information from suspects of terrorist activities, but only if they are hundred percent positive that the person is related to a terrorist activity. Many people will argue that I am cynical and that it is US's moral duty to help people as a democracy and not torture them. However, I believe it is okay to torture(and by torture I mean things that punish them to the furthest but before it kills them) evil people like terrorists because it will protect the country as a whole. We can sarifice one evil man for the millions of citizens' safety, can't we? And in a way they deserve torture because they were technically going to torture hundreds and thousands of innocent civilians with their terrorism anyway. A democracy should be able to protect the people within, thus using any means to stop any outside harm.
I do not believe that US should use whatever tactics necessary to extract information from terrorists, especially torture. Though it is the govt's duty to protect their people, I don't think this means violating others' rights - even if they're responsible for our harm. I think things like the Patriot Act (post 9/11) can be executed, but certainly not beating someone associated with terrorism, especially since there's never absolute proof that they're associated with it in the first place. Personally, I believe hat torturing is wrong, under any circumstances.
I think that the US should use anything necessary to get crucial information out of suspects. If that includes torture than so be it. I think by torturing these suspects we can get information that could really help us. For instance, if we caught a taliban memeber and tortured him to extract the whereabouts of Osama, then I think it is totally justified. Because Osama is a huge threat to the Safety of America. If we're extracting information for the safety of America I think it is totally justified.
I agree, I think that the US can use whatever means necessary to get information out of a suspect that is endangering our country. Hypothetically, if there is a terrorist who knows exactly when a terrorist attack is being planned and who is behind it, shouldnt we do whatever possible to get that information out of him? It is a choice between torturing a criminal, or risking the lives of thousands of innocent americans. In my opinion, we should sacrifice the terrorist.
I agree with Mina that US should only resort to torture if they have overwhelming evidence that the suspect knows information that would help US save many lives. This, of course, is very hard to achieve because there usually isn't that much evidence to support suspicion. It would mean that torture would be rarely used, so very strict regulations can serve as compromise between the supporters and the opposition.
Torture okay? NO! Just because there are threats being made against the United States does not mean that we can do whatever we want just to gain information. We shouldn't even be in Iraq in the first place. We are not the "World Police" and should stop acting like it. There is absolutely no reason that we should use punishment that is illegal in our country somewhere else that we are trying to bring democracy into...that's just wrong.
Torture is not okay no matter what the circumstances. Human beings are human beings and no one...and I mean no one...deserves to be treated like less of one. There has to be other ways to get information, but then again I can't think of any. Ms. Lal!! The Stevenson website is down! I can't get your email address. Can you send me the vocab list, if you look at this before Monday. My email is springgirl512@comcast.net. Thanks
Erik Halverson. P 4
Brandon, if we dont act as the world police then who will? whose job is it to protect the people in the world who cant protect themselves? put yourself in their position. Your family is being killed before your eyes, all of them are dead. Do you want help, of course, who do you look to for help, anyone who will offer. If we dont help, and no-one else does, and they wont, because as a wealthy country, the world looks to us for guidence, millions of people will die of starvation, murder, disease. I believe that if we have strong evidence that someone knows something that could potentially save american lives, even one american life, we should do all that we can to save those americans. This leads to the issue of do we torture to help other people. and i dont know. i think we need to help other people, but where do we draw the line? do we do all we can to help a british person? a french person? an israeli? an african? god forbid a muslim? where do we draw the line? thoughts?
Mina do you truly think that the US is ever 100% positive that a person has information or was plotting something? If they were why are they not tried in the courts and dealt with that way. I think that if we resort to torture in many ways we are no better than the terrorists. I understand that people have a great fear of terrorism, I am one of them, but if we give up rights the right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment, what right will we give away to the government next so they can protect us? If I was accused of having information while in a foreign country, I would hope that that country did not allow for torture.
I do not like that idea of torture and I think that it violates rights that every person has, but you have to put your self in the Gov.'s shoes, in that they know that if they could have prevented something from happening and the public finds out, the Gov. is in a lot of trouble. How else would we ever find out the truth, because people like that just don’t spill there guts.
Post a Comment