Is waterboarding torture? Why or why not? Should the US employ this tactic to gain intelligence??
25 comments:
Anonymous
said...
Yes waterboarding is torture, and yes America should use it to obtain information. Democracy and liberty are at stake not to mention millions of lives, and the Armed services must do whatever necessary to secure these fundemental rights as well as spread them. waterboarding is pyschological torture, and most likely as irreversible and severe as post-traumatic stress, but it is still necessary to obtain military intellegince because that is what wins the war, and secures freedom
Is waterboarding torture? Yes. Is it something we should use to obtain intel? Not at all...Why you ask. Because we advocate against cruel and unusual punishment, and I believe this would fall under that category. No torture at all.
I think that if the investigators are sure that they can obtain valuable information from the person, they can perform waterboarding. They are not killing the person, just speeding up their confession. Yes, torture is evil and I dont think that it should be done to innocent people..but.. if there is a huge threat to Americans i think we should use whatever means possible to obtain information
I think waterboarding is tortue and I think America shouldnt use it to obtain information. Although intelligence is vital information I agree with Brandon that we shouldn't use cruel and unusal punishment (8th ammendment) i think haha because then we are jsut being a hyprocratic nation!
Whether waterboarding is torture or not depends on the definition of torture. The government defines torture as physical damage, not psychological, so technically it isn't torture; however, the fact that there has been so much controversy about it signals for a change in the definition of torture. I think that torture should include both physical and psychological damage.
alex I per4 i agree with your first sentence "I think that if the investigators are sure that they can obtain valuable information from the person, they can perform waterboarding" the only problem with this is that we "knew" there was weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, but look what happens when we speculate. This is why i think waterboarding and other interrogation tactics that dont cause lasting damage should be used by secrective U.S. services.
Water boarding is not torture because it does no harm to a person and it is a good tactic to find out information. This method is only used to find very important information that may danger our country or people. I feel that it is okay to use water boarding because I see no harm in it.
It depends what you define as torture. I define torture as obtaining information forcefully by using a mental or physical harmful means. Therfore, waterboarding is torutre. I think this it is something that should be used in America. I think giving up one life is worthwhile as opposed to many people dying. If someone knows something where a lot of casualties can occur, I think it is ok to torture them to force the information out.
I definitely believe waterboarding is torture because I think torture is anything that will make a person be in physical, emotional, or psychological pain. And although it is torture, I believe that US should use this tactic in order to gain information that we need. And I think it is a good tactic too because it is not as bad as if we were seriously physically harming the person- it just makes them think it is suffocating them, so no actual damage is done but we get the information we need!
No, waterboarding is not torture, it doesn't actually hurt, and I believe that if it doesn't hurt, then it isn't torture. So yes of course the U.S. should use it to obtain information. You have to do whatever it takes to get information and keep our nation Safe!!
Yes, waterboarding is torture because like someone else said, it may not be the most painful thing there is, but it causes extreme emotional distress in a person through fear for their life. As we've seen lately it is extremely difficult to, beyond any reasonable doubt, say that one is completely certain that 'Iraq has weapons of mass destruction' or even convict someone of murder. If waterboarding is used by secret US operatives, it should be used very sparingly and only when they are certain that there is something that the tortured person has done that is extremely illegal and they can get useful information from them.
I agree with blake, it isnt physically harming someone, and if it can help save american lives then yes we should use waterboarding. What if someone might know something that could potentially lead the to army stopping a suicide bomber from blowing up 250 people. is the phschological "damage", which they will get over, not less imprtant then the lives of 250 innocent people? Erik Halverson
I think waterboarding is a kind of torture but certainly less scarring than most physical kinds. I know many argue that it's far worse than physical torture but I don't think so, because humans are very resilient and many overcome great psycological setbacks. I don't think waterboarding should be used liberally to gain intelligence, but if there is a strong lead and the lives of many are actually at stake, then waterboarding should be used as a last resort. I think if the safety of the nation's people are at stake, then it's worth it to secure vital military information.
I think waterboarding is without a doubt torture. To pour water over someone's head to make them feel like they are drowning, can't breathe and going to die is definitely torture. I think the question is whether or not this is acceptable to use to gather information. I don't know if it is momentarily ok to torture someone to prevent more deaths. The question is whether the ends justify the means.
I think waterboarding is without a doubt torture. To pour water over someone's head to make them feel like they are drowning, can't breathe and going to die is definitely torture. I think the question is whether or not this is acceptable to use to gather information. I don't know if it is momentarily ok to torture someone to prevent more deaths. The question is whether the ends justify the means.
I do believe that waterboarding is torture, but if someone is going to blow up New York then it is necessary. You have to be tough and the government thinks that they are doing by protecting use. I think that hurting people is just adding to worlds unhappiness but that is just the way things go. You can’t do mush about it, which is sad.
the FBI has said officially that waterboarding is not torture. extreme times call for extreme measures. the question is to what extent do we interrogate prisoners of war to abstract information that could be vital in saving american lives. if waterboarding isn't resulting in the deaths of these prisoners, but produces life saving informationg, then i support it. -JennaW
In general I am against all types of torture, if we as a nation don't act civilized how can we expect others to do it. We just can't pick and choose the moments we want to act and we have to set a standard that shows that even in the most extreme circumstances, we as a nation are willing to abide by our own principles. However, it is hard not to consider all extreme measures, including torture when faced with the situation when many may die and the person in custody might be in a situation to provide information to prevent those deaths from happening. Alexa C.
water boarding is torture. But I believe that we should use whatever can get us the best intelligence. Thousands of lives are in the balance and so to not get answers from prisoners would be criminal.
i know i commented on this blog before, but i have totally changed my mind. i just watched this video clip about waterboarding because i wasnt completely sure how it was done before, and it's SO BAD. we are americans, and we are better than that. that is just low and unintelligent to try and obtain intelligence by torchering someone. The person is more likely to give up false or misleading information just so the torture would stop. If we want to be a world power, we need to find a more intelligent and skillful way to obtain intelligence from terrorists- not by mounting them on a board and pouring water on them- how useless!
I agree that it is torture and it should be used. If the military can use it to get legit info on terrist attacks then i say go for it. I dont know the terrorists, but if i thot i were drowning id squeal like a pig.
before the military starts using waterboarding on suspects they should first learn how to keep a secret. i personally think there are plenty of military doings that are going on behind closed doors that we have no clue about, and waterboarding should be one of them. but maybe i think this just bcus i play alot of videogames
Yes Waterboarding is torture. We should not use it to ubtain information, because if we do who are we to say what is torture and what is not. Just because we say somthing is not torture doesnt mean that we are right. Matt Bass
Waterboarding is for sure torture. Let me ask you something. If you don't think it is torture, would you want to be waterboarded? I didn't think so! Many people don't know exactly what waterboarding is. It is drowning. They say its a controlled drowning, but that's only because there is a doctor witnessing the torture. Water is filling up the victim's lungs. Do I think America should use this method to obtain information that might save American lives? That is a tough question. America is known for protecting human rights. It's our ideals and morals that make America what it is. (the best country in the world). What puts us above terrorists or other countries is how we respect human rights. Also, torture leads to pain, and when someone is in pain, he/she will do/say anything just to make it stop. So torture does lead to false information that may lead America on wild goose chases wasting time. There are so many other methods to obtain information. For example: sleep deprivation, mind control drugs, good cop bad cop techniques, and verbal intimidation. In a way it is very hypocritical to be hurting the people that hurt us. Torture and finding answers should not be associated with revenge. Come on guys, this is America, we're better than that!
I disagree with chewy. For America to protect human rights we need to be proactive in expanding human rights where they are deprvied, and this is either by aiding the countries or in the situation of dictorial leadership we may need to use force to restore human rights. at this point just aiding Iraq is not possible so we are using force to oust the terrorist and restore order/peace. In WWII we did the same thing, we stormed the beaches (forcefully) to restore peace in Europe. Now whether its killing terrorists across the desert, defending ourselves from hostiles in crowded cities, carpet bombing the beaches of France before we invade, or waterboarding terrorists who would kill you if they got the chance, i think these are necessary actions for America to defend itself and others. As well as in the long term, restore human rights.
25 comments:
Yes waterboarding is torture, and yes America should use it to obtain information. Democracy and liberty are at stake not to mention millions of lives, and the Armed services must do whatever necessary to secure these fundemental rights as well as spread them. waterboarding is pyschological torture, and most likely as irreversible and severe as post-traumatic stress, but it is still necessary to obtain military intellegince because that is what wins the war, and secures freedom
Is waterboarding torture? Yes. Is it something we should use to obtain intel? Not at all...Why you ask. Because we advocate against cruel and unusual punishment, and I believe this would fall under that category. No torture at all.
I think that if the investigators are sure that they can obtain valuable information from the person, they can perform waterboarding. They are not killing the person, just speeding up their confession. Yes, torture is evil and I dont think that it should be done to innocent people..but.. if there is a huge threat to Americans i think we should use whatever means possible to obtain information
I think waterboarding is tortue and I think America shouldnt use it to obtain information. Although intelligence is vital information I agree with Brandon that we shouldn't use cruel and unusal punishment (8th ammendment) i think haha because then we are jsut being a hyprocratic nation!
mMike Auerbach
Whether waterboarding is torture or not depends on the definition of torture. The government defines torture as physical damage, not psychological, so technically it isn't torture; however, the fact that there has been so much controversy about it signals for a change in the definition of torture. I think that torture should include both physical and psychological damage.
alex I per4 i agree with your first sentence "I think that if the investigators are sure that they can obtain valuable information from the person, they can perform waterboarding" the only problem with this is that we "knew" there was weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, but look what happens when we speculate. This is why i think waterboarding and other interrogation tactics that dont cause lasting damage should be used by secrective U.S. services.
Water boarding is not torture because it does no harm to a person and it is a good tactic to find out information. This method is only used to find very important information that may danger our country or people. I feel that it is okay to use water boarding because I see no harm in it.
It depends what you define as torture. I define torture as obtaining information forcefully by using a mental or physical harmful means. Therfore, waterboarding is torutre. I think this it is something that should be used in America. I think giving up one life is worthwhile as opposed to many people dying. If someone knows something where a lot of casualties can occur, I think it is ok to torture them to force the information out.
I definitely believe waterboarding is torture because I think torture is anything that will make a person be in physical, emotional, or psychological pain. And although it is torture, I believe that US should use this tactic in order to gain information that we need. And I think it is a good tactic too because it is not as bad as if we were seriously physically harming the person- it just makes them think it is suffocating them, so no actual damage is done but we get the information we need!
No, waterboarding is not torture, it doesn't actually hurt, and I believe that if it doesn't hurt, then it isn't torture. So yes of course the U.S. should use it to obtain information. You have to do whatever it takes to get information and keep our nation Safe!!
Yes, waterboarding is torture because like someone else said, it may not be the most painful thing there is, but it causes extreme emotional distress in a person through fear for their life. As we've seen lately it is extremely difficult to, beyond any reasonable doubt, say that one is completely certain that 'Iraq has weapons of mass destruction' or even convict someone of murder. If waterboarding is used by secret US operatives, it should be used very sparingly and only when they are certain that there is something that the tortured person has done that is extremely illegal and they can get useful information from them.
I agree with blake, it isnt physically harming someone, and if it can help save american lives then yes we should use waterboarding. What if someone might know something that could potentially lead the to army stopping a suicide bomber from blowing up 250 people. is the phschological "damage", which they will get over, not less imprtant then the lives of 250 innocent people?
Erik Halverson
I think waterboarding is a kind of torture but certainly less scarring than most physical kinds. I know many argue that it's far worse than physical torture but I don't think so, because humans are very resilient and many overcome great psycological setbacks. I don't think waterboarding should be used liberally to gain intelligence, but if there is a strong lead and the lives of many are actually at stake, then waterboarding should be used as a last resort. I think if the safety of the nation's people are at stake, then it's worth it to secure vital military information.
I think waterboarding is without a doubt torture. To pour water over someone's head to make them feel like they are drowning, can't breathe and going to die is definitely torture. I think the question is whether or not this is acceptable to use to gather information. I don't know if it is momentarily ok to torture someone to prevent more deaths. The question is whether the ends justify the means.
I think waterboarding is without a doubt torture. To pour water over someone's head to make them feel like they are drowning, can't breathe and going to die is definitely torture. I think the question is whether or not this is acceptable to use to gather information. I don't know if it is momentarily ok to torture someone to prevent more deaths. The question is whether the ends justify the means.
I do believe that waterboarding is torture, but if someone is going to blow up New York then it is necessary. You have to be tough and the government thinks that they are doing by protecting use. I think that hurting people is just adding to worlds unhappiness but that is just the way things go. You can’t do mush about it, which is sad.
the FBI has said officially that waterboarding is not torture. extreme times call for extreme measures. the question is to what extent do we interrogate prisoners of war to abstract information that could be vital in saving american lives. if waterboarding isn't resulting in the deaths of these prisoners, but produces life saving informationg, then i support it.
-JennaW
In general I am against all types of torture, if we as a nation don't act civilized how can we expect others to do it. We just can't pick and choose the moments we want to act and we have to set a standard that shows that even in the most extreme circumstances, we as a nation are willing to abide by our own principles. However, it is hard not to consider all extreme measures, including torture when faced with the situation when many may die and the person in custody might be in a situation to provide information to prevent those deaths from happening.
Alexa C.
water boarding is torture. But I believe that we should use whatever can get us the best intelligence. Thousands of lives are in the balance and so to not get answers from prisoners would be criminal.
Barrett
i know i commented on this blog before, but i have totally changed my mind. i just watched this video clip about waterboarding because i wasnt completely sure how it was done before, and it's SO BAD. we are americans, and we are better than that. that is just low and unintelligent to try and obtain intelligence by torchering someone. The person is more likely to give up false or misleading information just so the torture would stop. If we want to be a world power, we need to find a more intelligent and skillful way to obtain intelligence from terrorists- not by mounting them on a board and pouring water on them- how useless!
I agree that it is torture and it should be used. If the military can use it to get legit info on terrist attacks then i say go for it. I dont know the terrorists, but if i thot i were drowning id squeal like a pig.
Jeff G
before the military starts using waterboarding on suspects they should first learn how to keep a secret. i personally think there are plenty of military doings that are going on behind closed doors that we have no clue about, and waterboarding should be one of them. but maybe i think this just bcus i play alot of videogames
Yes Waterboarding is torture. We should not use it to ubtain information, because if we do who are we to say what is torture and what is not. Just because we say somthing is not torture doesnt mean that we are right.
Matt Bass
Waterboarding is for sure torture. Let me ask you something. If you don't think it is torture, would you want to be waterboarded? I didn't think so! Many people don't know exactly what waterboarding is. It is drowning. They say its a controlled drowning, but that's only because there is a doctor witnessing the torture. Water is filling up the victim's lungs. Do I think America should use this method to obtain information that might save American lives? That is a tough question. America is known for protecting human rights. It's our ideals and morals that make America what it is. (the best country in the world). What puts us above terrorists or other countries is how we respect human rights. Also, torture leads to pain, and when someone is in pain, he/she will do/say anything just to make it stop. So torture does lead to false information that may lead America on wild goose chases wasting time. There are so many other methods to obtain information. For example: sleep deprivation, mind control drugs, good cop bad cop techniques, and verbal intimidation. In a way it is very hypocritical to be hurting the people that hurt us. Torture and finding answers should not be associated with revenge. Come on guys, this is America, we're better than that!
LAL 4 PREZ
I disagree with chewy. For America to protect human rights we need to be proactive in expanding human rights where they are deprvied, and this is either by aiding the countries or in the situation of dictorial leadership we may need to use force to restore human rights. at this point just aiding Iraq is not possible so we are using force to oust the terrorist and restore order/peace. In WWII we did the same thing, we stormed the beaches (forcefully) to restore peace in Europe. Now whether its killing terrorists across the desert, defending ourselves from hostiles in crowded cities, carpet bombing the beaches of France before we invade, or waterboarding terrorists who would kill you if they got the chance, i think these are necessary actions for America to defend itself and others. As well as in the long term, restore human rights.
Support Our Troops
Post a Comment