Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Thursday, December 13, 2007

School searches

Did the school violate Jordan's right to the 4th amendment by searching in her intimate areas?? Why or why not.... Should the schools need more than reasonable suspicion?

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think that if the school had searched everything else, it would have been reasonable. However, by looking into her pants and stuff, that is just wrong. She could have felt violated, and the school could have used another way to search her (for example, without the secretary watching??). I think that schools can have reasonable suspicion and that is enough, but this case is different because of the circumstances. also, if it were a boy, it would have been differnet.

Anonymous said...

I don't think the school necessarily violated Jordan's right to the 4th amendment because the 4th amendment states that people have the right "against unreasonable searches and seizures" and I believe the search against Jordan was not unreasonable (thus reasonable). The school had enough evidence (because it was a school, and not a police) and things like drugs and weapons can be harmful to not only herself, but to others as well- thus is enough to search in her intimate areas.

Anonymous said...

I think that in most cases the school should be able to search a student even if it is a strip search. a school is a place were there are many students in very influential stages of their lives and the school should do whatever they need to maintain a clean and safe learning environment.

cookies

Anonymous said...

I agree with Mina. Schools should be safe places. If a middle school kid has a razor, is dealing drugs, and has a stash of cigarettes in her binder, she probably has more stuff on her. I think that so long as the search was conducted in a way that did not harm her, there is nothing wrong with it. If she feels "emotionally traumatized", its her fault for bringing drugs and weapons to school. The school was well within its perogative to search her bra for hidden drugs. If someone were dealing drugs at my children's school, I would want that person searched and arrested.

Barrett

David Yim said...

I think that the search was legit. I mean they already found other things on her. A lot of girls can hide things in their bras...but searching the underwear...idk thats kinda weird. If i were the searcher (speaking as a girl of course). I'd feel pretty ackward and grossed out. I think that they were only trying to find more evidence and it was ok because it wasn't the police doing the searching it was the school.

Anonymous said...

I personally don't think that it was right of the school to have searched her like that especially with other people watching. The school had every right so search her, but not in those areas.

stasey 4