Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

Supreme Court

Should the US Supreme Court give the enemy detainees at Gitmo their habeas rights? Why or why not.

3 comments:

Enrique said...

I dont think so. I think that the people in Gitmo are there because of intelligence that says they either were affiliated with, or were aiding and abiting terrorist groups. and for the safty of our country, they should be locked up. I think they should have a right to appeal their holding, but i dont think it should happen in a normal court, their cases should be held in a military court in Gitmo

Anonymous said...

No. The Ameican Constitution and American Rights are meant for American Citizens. If Cubans want Habeaus Corpus they need to create their own stable government that will provide it to them.

Anonymous said...

No. Habeas Corpus is a right of American citizens. They are not Americans. We should treat them like POWs. They are at war with the US, so they are enemy combatants and should be given those rights. Why should they be granted habeas corpus?

Barrett