Should America embrace comparativism? Should America be guided by other countries' Constitutions? Why or why not...
8 comments:
Anonymous
said...
I think America should not be guided by other countries' Constitutions. It is important to ignore "peer pressure." Our Constitution should only include what is best for our country. We should completely disregard laws in other countries' Constitutions if they are not in the best interest of our country.
I think that we should take interest in the political venues of other nations. Sure they may not be in out best interest, but the exposure to different interpretations of government might open up a window to a different aspect of government leadership. We should not though be ruled by in international bylaw dictating our actions and their legality. We have worked so hard to develop and adhere to our governing documents, it would be stupid to let them be swept under the rug.
From a legal standpoint, we've got no right to do so without the necessary channels of law. Our constitution was written for our country and our country alone, much like other political doctrines across the world. I'm not opposed to empirical thinking, and I'll agree that our friends and allies may have wonderful ideas that could be incorporated into our government system, but without passing these laws through all 3 branches of government, we've got no right to abide by any other country's legal or moral standards. We have numerous organizations for international law, like the U.N., but ultimately their concerns should be international issues such as military action or human rights, not individual countries' legal systems.
Im not saying I totally disagree with Jordan but isnt what he said a bit contradictory? I get what he's saying but...What if making the constitution the for the betterment of this nation includes looking at other nations laws' and policies? The death penalty has been at the center of this controversy for quite a period. Should the US abolish capital punishment like most of the rest of the world or should it continue killing people?
I saw the news tonight that Hillary Clinton won the Florida Primary, and as I was watching the video, I thought that what she was promising - a solution to all the problems - was too much. She talked about how Americans finally care and how she wants people to rest assured that things will get better with the economy, college tuition, etc. It seemed like she's way over her head, but people were very supportive of what she was saying. Making promises like that to a desperate country will win her over now, but if she can't keep up with her promises, her ratings may be like Bush's.
In the article we read two nights ago, it said that "30 % of our GNP us internationally derived."...this means that our economy is effected enormously by other counties. Alot of times, if the economy is prospering, then it causes the people to put more faith in the government...with that being said, i feel that it is extremely important to take into account decisions that have been made by other countries. Especially Human rights laws. this is not an issue specific to America, it is universal, and we can all learn from each other.
Just to counter what Jake said... The GNP is the Gross NATIONAL Product, versus the GDP which is the Gross DOMESTIC Product. The idea is that our GNP is taking into account National profits made overseas, such as the sale of GM cars in other countries. Saying that at least 30% of our GNP comes from outside the U.S. is the equivalent of saying that at least 30% of our international sales comes from overseas -- it's relatively redundant and insignificant; a much better measure of the U.S.'s wealth is the GDP. Nonetheless, saying that 30% of our GNP is international makes it seem like the U.S. is largely dependent on the other countries of the world, but from a purely economic standpoint, we're the strongest economic power on the face of the earth. If we're going to turn this into an economic argument rather than a legal or moral one, other countries should bend to fit OUR constitution and not vice versa.
8 comments:
I think America should not be guided by other countries' Constitutions. It is important to ignore "peer pressure." Our Constitution should only include what is best for our country. We should completely disregard laws in other countries' Constitutions if they are not in the best interest of our country.
I think that we should take interest in the political venues of other nations. Sure they may not be in out best interest, but the exposure to different interpretations of government might open up a window to a different aspect of government leadership. We should not though be ruled by in international bylaw dictating our actions and their legality. We have worked so hard to develop and adhere to our governing documents, it would be stupid to let them be swept under the rug.
From a legal standpoint, we've got no right to do so without the necessary channels of law. Our constitution was written for our country and our country alone, much like other political doctrines across the world. I'm not opposed to empirical thinking, and I'll agree that our friends and allies may have wonderful ideas that could be incorporated into our government system, but without passing these laws through all 3 branches of government, we've got no right to abide by any other country's legal or moral standards. We have numerous organizations for international law, like the U.N., but ultimately their concerns should be international issues such as military action or human rights, not individual countries' legal systems.
I agree with Mr. Sheer, in fact seeing that our constitution is the oldest one in use other nations should be following our ideals and decisions
Im not saying I totally disagree with Jordan but isnt what he said a bit contradictory? I get what he's saying but...What if making the constitution the for the betterment of this nation includes looking at other nations laws' and policies? The death penalty has been at the center of this controversy for quite a period. Should the US abolish capital punishment like most of the rest of the world or should it continue killing people?
I saw the news tonight that Hillary Clinton won the Florida Primary, and as I was watching the video, I thought that what she was promising - a solution to all the problems - was too much. She talked about how Americans finally care and how she wants people to rest assured that things will get better with the economy, college tuition, etc. It seemed like she's way over her head, but people were very supportive of what she was saying. Making promises like that to a desperate country will win her over now, but if she can't keep up with her promises, her ratings may be like Bush's.
In the article we read two nights ago, it said that "30 % of our GNP us internationally derived."...this means that our economy is effected enormously by other counties. Alot of times, if the economy is prospering, then it causes the people to put more faith in the government...with that being said, i feel that it is extremely important to take into account decisions that have been made by other countries. Especially Human rights laws. this is not an issue specific to America, it is universal, and we can all learn from each other.
Just to counter what Jake said... The GNP is the Gross NATIONAL Product, versus the GDP which is the Gross DOMESTIC Product. The idea is that our GNP is taking into account National profits made overseas, such as the sale of GM cars in other countries. Saying that at least 30% of our GNP comes from outside the U.S. is the equivalent of saying that at least 30% of our international sales comes from overseas -- it's relatively redundant and insignificant; a much better measure of the U.S.'s wealth is the GDP. Nonetheless, saying that 30% of our GNP is international makes it seem like the U.S. is largely dependent on the other countries of the world, but from a purely economic standpoint, we're the strongest economic power on the face of the earth. If we're going to turn this into an economic argument rather than a legal or moral one, other countries should bend to fit OUR constitution and not vice versa.
Post a Comment