Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

NEW TLO Case

Did the schools act inappropriately during the search of the student? Read the full article below to respond.

www.nytimes.com/2009/03/24/us/24savana.html?hp

4 comments:

Rach said...

There is no question on this. What the school did was completely inappropriate. They have no right to do that to anyone, especially a 13 year old girl. She was only thought to be carrying around prescription advil which isnt even that bad. If it was something more dangerous, or illegal drugs, they would have more reason to search her, but not a strip search. Schools have no place violating anyone like that. Its disgusting. And if a male teacher had done that, it would be completely illegal, so what makes it ok for another female to do that? NO ONE should be allowed to do that at a school.

Nicole Duda said...

I completely agree with Rachel. If the drug was to be something more serious, I would maybe understand a little bit more, but still disagree with the way that the school tried to handle the "situation." No child should be treated like that, especially a 13 year old girl. Schools are supposed to make you feel safe, how is this making you feel safe or comfortable?

sexy beast! said...

This is just insane that a school is able to strip search somebody when all they have is "suspicion." Basically the school is saying that I can go tell my dean I suspect that a kid has drugs on them and they will automatically just go strip search that person. It's ridiculous. It's crazy. If anything call the parents and have the parents look, but how far did the school really think they could go? And the most disgusting thing from this whole story?...Well, thats the fact that the two people searching her didn't refuse to stop. Didn't they believe this was wrong to do? Do we really want somebody that doesn't realize a strip search is not just ethically wrong, but morally degrading teaching children?

Osman said...

The school was not justified in its actions in this case. The school went way too far than any school should under these circumstances. It is not as though the student was suspected as having illicit drugs on her, nor was she suspected of dealing them. I feel that "reasonable suspicion" gives schools too much power in this respect, however, the hard part is finding the balance between keeping schools safe and avoiding incidents such as this one.