Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Thursday, April 09, 2009

Nukes Nukes Nukes

Is Obama's assertion in Prague, A nonnuclear World, a fantasy? Why or why not. Does America need nukes? Should America stop countries from obtaining nukes? Why or why not.

4 comments:

sexy beast! said...

Yes, it is a fantasy. While Obama and many others may want a world without nukes it is not going to happen anytime in the near future and i can't see it ever happening. America does needs nukes, as it is one of the most powerful, if not the most powerful country in the world. We would look weak to everybody else if we didn't have them. Also, if a place like North Korea does indeed have nukes, then we need them to protect ourselves and not leave ourselves vulnerable.

Anonymous said...

Of course its a fantasy, the world is too advanced to not have nukes. Also no one will agree to not have nukes, who's going to tell them, the UN? Also the U.S does need nukes to protect ourselves against crazy people. America should try and stop other people from getting nukes but thats not going to happen and sadly, if one nuke goes, the whole world is screwed so nukes suck.

Sunah Choi said...

Of course Obama's assertion of a nonnuclear world is a fantasy. Even before World World II, countries have made an agreement in which they were to limit the size of their armies. Yet, this agreement only lasted so long, for Hitler created an enormous army, which overthrew almost every country in Europe. This proves that even with limitations placed through laws, there will always be those kind of people that go against policies and are power-driven. In a world where nuclear bombs can define the power of a country, America needs nukes for safety purposes. America can try stopping countries from obtaining nukes, but we must know our limitations for going too far can cause the outbreak of nuclear war.

Nik Arun said...

I believe that this situation is very similar to that of the automobile industry in terms of alternative energy. Now, I'm sure all of us agree that hybrid/electric/etc cars would be beneficial to the environment and to the world in general, similar to how most would suggest that an Nuke free world is better than a world that can literally now be destroyed in the blink of an eye. Here's how I see it: in the car industry, in order to move to alternative fuels, one company has to innitiate the movement. This company is now put at a disadvantage because initially the alternative fuels will be more expensive and there will be less demand for them. Looking at nulcear weapons, lets say that the US decides to get rid of all of its nukes in an attempt to start a path to a nuke free world. Well now, the US is at the mercy of all the countries left with nukes. This is the problem, there is too much chaos in the world right now for there to be a unanimous global agreement to ben nukes, and even if a country with good intentions hopes to set a good example by getting rid of their nukes, they will be put at a HEAVY disadvantage in terms of military power until other countries chose to do so. No country wants to be put in that situation, and that's why we aren't seeing change.

Getting back to the car analogy though, in terms of cars that run on alternative fuels, if a company is willing to take the risk to move to more environmentally friendly automobiles, even though the short term income of the company will decline, it is assured that after some time, other companies will follow the example set and do the same. Once enough company's do this, subsidies will be engaged for these new cars and these new cars will actually result in a profit in the long term. Okay back to nukes: if other countries follow the example of a countrey brave enough to remove its nukes, then soon we will see a drastic reduction in WOMD and a much safer world as a result.

"ok nik, we get it, but what's the point of talking about cars". well, you see, cars are something we can relate to more: i dont't think anyone has a problem with switching from gasoline to hybrid especially is the net result is a benefit to both the environment and economy. But with nukes, you guys think that nukes are so powerful and above the influence of the public, that there's no way we could get rid of them. This is not the correct thought process; all we need is one country brave enough to innitiate the removal of nukes, and other countries will follow. Having nukes merely makes a country feel safer and increase their sense of security. Some may call my views farfetched, but I believe that all humans have a sense of innate goodness in them, and nobody wants to see death and destruction occur. Though nothing is certain, I have optimism that one day the world will be nuke free.