Did the school violate the students' right to privacy in their search? Why or why not.
4 comments:
Anonymous
said...
The school should have been able to search the backpack but should not have been allowed to search the student down to her underwear and require her to shake it out. A patdown or frisk should have been enough. Underwear is supposed to cover someone's "private parts" and that person should not have to expose them to school officials who are looking for a harmless, legal drug when these officials are searching this girl on poor evidence. This violates a students' right to privacy and the search should have only gone this far with more evidence and proper warrants or reasoning. However, I do believe it was ok to search the backpack because it is important that the school try to stop drug abuse.
The school went way too far when they decided it would be okay to strip search that 13 year old girl. While kids at that age are already changing for gym, changing in a secluded locker room with a bunch of other girls going through the same changes as you are is a completely different story then being forced to remove your clothing in front of two adults because you were suspected of giving someone an advil. What is even more shocking to me is the fact that this was all over what is equal to a reccomended dosage of advil, an over the counter drug. I understand that schools need to protect their students and try to keep drug abuse out of schools, it is ridiculous to me that an administrator would go that far in a search for a dosage of ibuprofen that is listed on the bottle. Schools need to start involving students' parents before taking any actions against their children, or there are going to be serious problems resulting from quick decisions like this one.
In this case the school is going to far, there was no need to search that girl just because they suspected her having drugs. When the drugs were just over the counter advil. I realize that those are also not allowed in school, and they wanted to search to see if she had anymore but taking it to this degree is ridiculous.
It depends on location, but she might not even know why she had to do that, for most kids Advil is just something to make a headache go away, not like it causes major problems or anything.
I do understand that the school can search students based on very limited and incomplete information, but there is a limit to this. If schools start abusing the power that they hold by searching everyone that they figure might have something, some school is going to get into too much trouble, like in this story.
I'm gona be honest, this story made me mad because its obnoxious/very wrong to be stripping a 13 year old down to her undergarments. Yes girls change in the gym locker rooms for school but most girls wear tank tops or something to at least cover their bodies. There should've been a frisk rather than a stripping and shaking of the body. Imagine how the girl felt after. Humiliated? I would hope so, that's absolutely mortifying in my opinion. Imagine what they would do if the girl actually had heroine or something worse in her backpack. If they went that far for an over the counter, they're got a lot of problems.
4 comments:
The school should have been able to search the backpack but should not have been allowed to search the student down to her underwear and require her to shake it out. A patdown or frisk should have been enough. Underwear is supposed to cover someone's "private parts" and that person should not have to expose them to school officials who are looking for a harmless, legal drug when these officials are searching this girl on poor evidence. This violates a students' right to privacy and the search should have only gone this far with more evidence and proper warrants or reasoning. However, I do believe it was ok to search the backpack because it is important that the school try to stop drug abuse.
The school went way too far when they decided it would be okay to strip search that 13 year old girl. While kids at that age are already changing for gym, changing in a secluded locker room with a bunch of other girls going through the same changes as you are is a completely different story then being forced to remove your clothing in front of two adults because you were suspected of giving someone an advil. What is even more shocking to me is the fact that this was all over what is equal to a reccomended dosage of advil, an over the counter drug. I understand that schools need to protect their students and try to keep drug abuse out of schools, it is ridiculous to me that an administrator would go that far in a search for a dosage of ibuprofen that is listed on the bottle. Schools need to start involving students' parents before taking any actions against their children, or there are going to be serious problems resulting from quick decisions like this one.
In this case the school is going to far, there was no need to search that girl just because they suspected her having drugs. When the drugs were just over the counter advil. I realize that those are also not allowed in school, and they wanted to search to see if she had anymore but taking it to this degree is ridiculous.
It depends on location, but she might not even know why she had to do that, for most kids Advil is just something to make a headache go away, not like it causes major problems or anything.
I do understand that the school can search students based on very limited and incomplete information, but there is a limit to this. If schools start abusing the power that they hold by searching everyone that they figure might have something, some school is going to get into too much trouble, like in this story.
I'm gona be honest, this story made me mad because its obnoxious/very wrong to be stripping a 13 year old down to her undergarments. Yes girls change in the gym locker rooms for school but most girls wear tank tops or something to at least cover their bodies. There should've been a frisk rather than a stripping and shaking of the body. Imagine how the girl felt after. Humiliated? I would hope so, that's absolutely mortifying in my opinion. Imagine what they would do if the girl actually had heroine or something worse in her backpack. If they went that far for an over the counter, they're got a lot of problems.
Post a Comment