Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Friday, October 21, 2005

Stem Cell

Stem cell research-- opinions???

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

hey its oren, i forgot my pw so i'll blog anon... stem cells are myy topic! i've had real big debates on this because of the idea of using stem cells on my sister, we did it out of country. so obviously, im pro stem cell research and use. these cells are the only cells that are able to duplicate endlessly, also, stem cells have the ability to divide and duplicate indefinitely and are the ONLY cells that can do that! and because these cells are "smart" enough to know which cells are needed to repair damaged body parts or organs, why not take advantage of that? as far as cloning, i dont really care, but i think the idea of using cells to help people and save lives is a great idea

Anonymous said...

OREN HERE--- sup ladies? anyway
LAL- this is totally irrelevant to the blog, but u absolutely have to stop with these assignments.. this media thing is soooo out of line... i was expecting to read and article, answer a few questions and go to bed, u have me all over the internet and im getting pornographic pop ups!!! absolutely uncalled for. well gotta go finish the hw..
OREN

Yoda da Max said...

Stem Cell research was the topic of my Junior Research paper, so it is a topic I know all too well.

To begin, I'd like to point out that there are two major kinds of stem cells to research, adult, and embryonic. All the controversy over the embryonic stem cells has completely eclipsed any progress made with their adult counterparts. Research has shown that adult stem cells may be nearly as effective (if not as effective) as embryonic stem cells. There is absolutely no reason to oppose research using adult stem cells; embryonic stem cells (ESCs-it's a lot to type) are another story.

Until recent developments, I was completely opposed to ESC research, where in order to harvest stem cells, an embryo must be destroyed. In my mind, the embryo contains a human life, just waiting to be developed, and destroying it, for cold science (often times it is only for research, not even to treat illness--in fact, at the moment, treatment using stem cells of any sort is extremely rare) is akin to killing a life. Surprisingly, I am also pro-choice. I understand that the embryo is not a thinking human yet, but you should have a good reason to kill it. The aborted baby had a chance at life, and a mother that cared about it would make the decision to end its life, a stem cell embryo would not even have these luxuries. At the very least the taking of a life should not be part of a cold scientific research process. The greatest power in ESC research lies with therapeutic cloning, where a single cell from a living person is cloned to create an unlimited number of embryos that would show specific traits that scientists want to research, or could be transplanted into the same person without any risk of rejection. It is a powerful technique that could help many people, but it can also lead to a waste of human lives.

There have been two recent developments that may make my arguments unwarranted. The first is genetically modifying the skin cell that will be made into an embryo from which stem cells will be harvested so that it could never implant on a uterus, and never grow into a person. To me, this seems like killing before creation, not destroying a non-human. The second development is a technique to harvest stem cells without destroying the embryo. At first, this sounds like an ideal solution, but I have not been able to find how this extraction occurs, and if the embryo were allowed to develop, what effects this would have when it reaches adult-hood. Another question that needs to be answered before I can accept this technique is what will happen to the embryos after the ESCs have been harvested? Will they be put into cold storage for mothers wanting children, or will they be discarded after their usefulness has ended? It seems unlikely that these embryos would ever be allowed to grow and it seems a cruel fate to leave a human in such an undeveloped state. If you look at them as humans, embryos don't deserve such treatments, they should be considered heroes: they gave parts of themselves to help those in need, without even being given the option to refuse.

Of course, my objection to ESC research is not limited to this one point. Part of what scares me so much about ESC is that early human lives are dehumanized. They are treated as tools, not as people. They are not given the respect, nor the dignity, owed to all human life. The other day I watched THX 1138 (George Lucas's first movie) and in it after an industrial accident, the government announces that however many humans were "destroyed." It has a chilling effect when people are treated as things, and I fear that this is where we would be headed should ESC research be allowed. Another objection is the casual tinkering that scientists do with human DNA. Some is required to turn a human skin cell into an embryo that will grow the ESCs. Further modification is needed to ensure that embryos cannot grow into humans. These modifications to the human genome could be the forerunners to custom-made children, or genetic modification parlors. These are not powers I believe man should not toy around with his (or her) own building blocks; this is a path that will eventually lead to disaster.

To summarize, I don't believe that we should use ESC until all the power of adult stem cells has been exploited. It is indeed a miraculous breakthrough in science, but we should not forget that it is not technology: it is alive.

I would also like to mention that this post is heavily biased, and I have left out many of the benefits that adult and ESC research can bring humanity. But since most people already see these as such great things, I don't think that it is necessary (besides, this took long enough to type as it is, and it isn't even graded!). Feel free to do your own research and tell me that embryos are not alive. It is a personal belief. It cannot be scientifically proven (nor denied). Only metaphors can be provided. Here is my favorite that I made up some time ago while arguing with a friend: A person is like a car, before conception, it is a shell without a motor, or a motor without wheels. In the case of stem cell embryos, it would be a car without keys, all the parts are there, but it could not drive you anywhere until somebody puts in the key (activates the genes that would transform an ordinary cell into an embryo). At that point, everything is in place for that car to go anywhere. It is a person, however undeveloped.

PS: I spellchecked this in word after writing it online, it is nearly 1000 words and spans three full pages. Why can't English assignments be so fun, fast, and easy?