Spent, is it? I agree that the lives of American soldiers come first, but try looking at things from the other side:
Despite the fact that the media does not feel the need to justify their choices, there are good reasons to not help our troops.
Jennings wasn't embarressed because he had missed the oppurtunity for a great story that would get amazing ratings, it is because he had given up his journalistic impartiality. As a journalist, he is supposed to report the news, with as little bias as possible, and without creating the news. Try comparing this situation to another that requires impartiality, such as happens in the medical proffession. Say that you are testing a new wonder-drug that you're fairly certain would be able to treat cancer. In a normal, however simplified, scientific study half of the test group would recieve the drug, and the other half would recieve a placebo. The Jennings choice of action in this situation would be to give the drug to both groups, helping more people, but ruining the study. Wallace would do as any good scientist should, he would conduct the study normally, only give the drug to half the people, and see the actual results. Of course, impartialty in journalism is less important (and common) than in medicine, but it is an admirable goal.
Further reasons to not help the troops would include the fact that the journalists would probably have signed a contract saying that they would not do that in order to work with the Kosanese. Should one violate this trust, not only will they not recieve later oppurtunities to report from behind enemy lines, but it is likely that all the journalists would be imprisoned, or worse.
Lives would be at stake with my example too, especially if you know that the drug will work. Scientists and journalists are both supposed to be impartial about what they report. But as I said in the beginning of my post, I agree that the journalist should try to help the American troops.
2 comments:
Spent, is it? I agree that the lives of American soldiers come first, but try looking at things from the other side:
Despite the fact that the media does not feel the need to justify their choices, there are good reasons to not help our troops.
Jennings wasn't embarressed because he had missed the oppurtunity for a great story that would get amazing ratings, it is because he had given up his journalistic impartiality. As a journalist, he is supposed to report the news, with as little bias as possible, and without creating the news. Try comparing this situation to another that requires impartiality, such as happens in the medical proffession.
Say that you are testing a new wonder-drug that you're fairly certain would be able to treat cancer. In a normal, however simplified, scientific study half of the test group would recieve the drug, and the other half would recieve a placebo. The Jennings choice of action in this situation would be to give the drug to both groups, helping more people, but ruining the study. Wallace would do as any good scientist should, he would conduct the study normally, only give the drug to half the people, and see the actual results.
Of course, impartialty in journalism is less important (and common) than in medicine, but it is an admirable goal.
Further reasons to not help the troops would include the fact that the journalists would probably have signed a contract saying that they would not do that in order to work with the Kosanese. Should one violate this trust, not only will they not recieve later oppurtunities to report from behind enemy lines, but it is likely that all the journalists would be imprisoned, or worse.
Lives would be at stake with my example too, especially if you know that the drug will work. Scientists and journalists are both supposed to be impartial about what they report.
But as I said in the beginning of my post, I agree that the journalist should try to help the American troops.
Post a Comment