Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Sunday, September 16, 2007

Capital Punishment

Is the death penalty a violation of our 8th amendment? Do we need it? Why or why not...

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

i dont think the death penalty is a violation of the 8th amendment because those who deserve to die should die. murderers, for example, should always receive the death penalty because to not take away their life after committing muder would be a crime in itself.

-aaj4me915-

Abby said...

I do not think that capital punishment violates our 8th ammendment, because there would (hopefully) be good cause for it, however I do not think we should have the death penalty for other reasons. I think that jail for life is more of a punishment than dying, because the death penalty almost seems like 'the easy way out' as opposed to be in jail for the rest of your years.

Kaitin Rigney said...

I do not believe in capital punishment. I think that a life time in jail is more of a punishment then death. But I do not believe that is violates are 8th amendment.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Abby and Kaitlin. The death penalty, in my opinion, is not a violation of our eight ammendment. If a murderer forces death upon someone, they deserve a harsh punishment, such as death themsleves. However, death penalty should not always be given because life in jail is a more drawn out punishment, which makes the criminal feel punished, unlike death, where they only feel physical pain, as opposed to emotional and mental strain from being in jail for the rest of your life.

Anonymous said...

i have mixed feelings about capital punishment. i agree with kaitin that life in jail is more of a punishment than death because you have to live out your entire life miserably stuck behind bars, whereas the death penalty could be seen as an "easy way out". and in most cases, i just don't think it's right for us to decide who should die and who should live. we're punishing those who murdered someone (or multiple people) by having them murdered? i just think it seems kind of contradictory. but on the other hand, people like Sadam Hussein "deserve" the death penalty because the crime he committed is just so outrageous and intolerable.
-jennaw

barrett said...

In no way does capital punishment violate the 8th amendment. Death is not unusual, it happens all the time. People kill each other (usually why someone ends up on death row). Also, death is not cruel. Harsh, yes, but not cruel. Crimes need punishment and no prison term is long enough when you murder another person.

Barrett

Anonymous said...

If the question is just looked at objectively, then I believe death penalty is kind of a violation to our 8th amendment rights because the way the murders are killed is cruel- using the same dosage of potassium chloride(?) for all different kinds of people. However, capital punishment is needed because as older people say, "an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth". If they had ended some innocent person's life, they deserve to die along with them. Many people above said that they thought a life imprisonment was a better alternative to capital punishment; however, with murders, if they were crazy enough to kill someone from the beginning, they will almost never regret their actions even if in jail.

Anonymous said...

i dont think it is a violation of the 8th amendment, but i disagree with Kaitin. murderers, rapists, and other horrible people deserve to pay the ultimate price for their disgusting crimes. also i dont want my tax dollars paying to feed people like jeffery dohmer.

Nelly-5 said...

I agree with what Alex said. The death penalty is a harsh punishment, but it is less of a punishment that spending your entire life in jail. Also, it can also be the case where more evidence is found for the case to find a person innocent, like what happened with Illinois and the college students who found evidence to prove the acuused innocent. If this is the case, the person can be released from prison. Besides, the people on death row spends years in jail awaiting death anyway.

Anonymous said...

The death penalt as it exists now in the US is rediculously ineffective at preventing crime. Unfortunately, the death penalty as it should be enforced would be a horrific violation of the 8th amendment. If the government wishes to implement capital punishment, it should be done within a reasonable time of conviction (no more messing about with death row for 20 yrs, no more endless appeals system) and should be attached to a system of corporal punishment to replace the current incarceration system. My point is that if you want capital punishment to work, it should be worse than what a criminal faces in the course of his activities. Most drug lords would welcome lethal injection compared to what their rivals would do to them.\

In addition to the problems with capital punishment, the prison system serves now more as a place for criminals to learn from each other than a place to rehabilitate the deviant. Instead, an almost Hammurabian system of corporal punishment would be much more effective at preventing crime. To give a practical example, a shoplifter would think twice if he knew getting caught would mean the loss of his hand. Unfortunately, none of this jives with the 8th amendment. The 8th amendment prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. That diction has evolved in meaning over the years, as when it was written, hanging was a perfectly legitimate punishment. So there might even be a further question in this: Is the 8th amendment neccessary? Is it the government's duty to occasionally be cruel?

Oh...hi, Lal!

Anonymous said...

i do not think that it is a violation of the 8th amendment, but I think that it depends on certain cases. In my opinion, I think that keeping the criminal in jail for their entire life is a better punishment than just death...But at the same time, someone that has done something terrible may deserve death as well.

stasey g

Anonymous said...

I think the death penalty is a violation of the 8th amendment. The death penalty is so final and definite, it just doesn't seem right. Usually I believe in "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" but this time it just doesn't seem to apply. I think that a lifetime in jail is a more suitable punishment.

Anonymous said...

I do think that the death penalty is a violation of our eight amendment rights. Also I don’t see how killing someone because they killed someone is beneficial. I think the death penalty is hypocritical by telling people that they can't kill people but then turning around and killing them. I think life in jail is way more beneficial.

Anonymous said...

I feel that the death penalty does violate the 8th amendment in a way. I feel that a life sentence to jail is a much more ethical way of handling criminal situations. Like many people have said, this life sentence in jail is a lifetime of suffering and punishment. However, the death penalty ends all pain. They aren't really getting mental punishment. Instead, they're getting out of their punishment by dieing right away.

Monica W. p.4