Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Whitney Young

Should the Whitney Young students be expelled? Why or why not... Should schools be able to discipline students outside their property?

4 comments:

Rach said...

I think they should be expelled. What they did was against the law and when they were at the game, they were representing their school. The students were chosen over other teens to be accepted into the high school. Attending that school is a privilege because they could have just gone to a regular public school. They did something wrong and should lose their chance to go there; however, if it was another school like stevenson, i dont think they would deserve expulsion because that is the high school they have to go to and there wouldnt be another place to go. Even then, they would still deserve a punishment.

Nicole Duda said...

I don't think that they should get expelled, but I do think that they deserve punishment. Its the same for Stevenson, if you do something wrong outside of school, especially for a school event, you will get school consequences. I think that this is fair so instead of just police or parents kids worry about, they also have to think about how the school will react to what they want to do. This could help kids with the realization that what their doing could be wrong and could effect their entire future.

Sunah Choi said...

I think that they deserve punishment, but expelling the students is a bit too harsh. Suspension or LOP are both more reasonable alternatives. Realistically, any student could have done what they did. What they did was wrong, but will completely removing those students from the school body be effective in teaching others a lesson? I think that both the students and their mistakes will be forgotten. Therefore, the means of punishment aren't creating the desired impact on the rest of the students.

Ryan Marcus said...

I find it ridiculous that expulsion is even considered as a solution to something like this. One mistake and their entire education is destroyed? They weren't playing drunk, driving drunk, being drunk in public or at school; they were drunk at a hotel, celebrating their season and playoff success. Yes what they did is inexcusable and wrong and illegal, but they're kids that are excited and not too concerned about consequences at the moment. They should be punished and made examples of, but by no means should their education be put at risk for one mistake off campus that affected no one but themselves.
In response to Rachel's comment more directly, the school is a privilege to attend, but they were intelligent enough to get there and had no previous histories. One mistake cannot discredit a person so much that their foundation of their life is stripped from them and they are forced out in to inadequate public schools because they made a fundamental mistake that half the teenage nation makes every weekend. Expulsion is only on the plate because they were representing the school--any other student i'm sure would be faced with a different punishment. The students should be treated no differently than any other because off campus they are individuals who are attending a school, not students constantly quaking in fear of a big brother establishment set for education not life control.