Does Mrs. Lal have awesome jokes?

Thursday, October 27, 2005

Liberty vs. Authority

Should the White House and the executive branch install digital chips into our passports to reveal our personal information. Is this a necessary provision to combat terrorism and provide safety or is this an intrusion and an usurpation of our liberty? Is this an example of the "imperial presidency"? Explain your blog response.

Articles to provide information:
http://networks.silicon.com/lans/0,39024663,39153665,00.htm
or:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/10/25/AR2005102501624.html

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I would have to say that inserting chips into our passports would make things so much easier and quicker. one way or another, this information is accessable to many people whether it be hackers or the federal govt. Although it is clearly a violation of a citizen's right to privacy i think it is just another precaution we could eventually take. If there is a problem, for example, how easy would it be just to look up the info when the person hands you the pass so you can take care of it right on the spot. If it is a matter of protecting us and national security, why not take that risk?

Anonymous said...

I would have to say that inserting chips into our passports would make things so much easier and quicker. one way or another, this information is accessable to many people whether it be hackers or the federal govt. Although it is clearly a violation of a citizen's right to privacy i think it is just another precaution we could eventually take. If there is a problem, for example, how easy would it be just to look up the info when the person hands you the pass so you can take care of it right on the spot. If it is a matter of protecting us and national security, why not take that risk?

Anonymous said...

I would have to say that inserting chips into our passports would make things so much easier and quicker. one way or another, this information is accessable to many people whether it be hackers or the federal govt. Although it is clearly a violation of a citizen's right to privacy i think it is just another precaution we could eventually take. If there is a problem, for example, how easy would it be just to look up the info when the person hands you the pass so you can take care of it right on the spot. If it is a matter of protecting us and national security, why not take that risk?
P.S Ms. Lal, I'm sorry that i published this 3 times but i couldn't remember my password so i did it under anonymous. thanks
~Lindsey F

Anonymous said...

who cares? chips or no chips, they can find out whatever they want, when they want. the fbi, cia, and all those agencies can find out whatever they want, if someones wanted, as soon as their name pops up on a computer everyone knows, chips wouldn't make a difference. oh, and becasue im jewish, would we have to pay for these chips being inserted? cuz that would be rediculous. so in a sense i agree wtih putting them in, and in a sense, i dont really care. so what the hell, why not!

ODIZZ

AGNES M. said...

I'd have to agree with Mike, while both of the articles presented the topic with a rather negative spin on things, this new innovation is a great way of expediting travel and generally bringing a higher standard of security to international travel. While opposing viewpoints hold some validity in the belief that this technology can eventually be hacked and falsified -- such concerns persist anyways with our modern system, the forgery of passports and other identifying papers being a present security issue. If anything then, the addition of another level of security in the form of a chip can only make this process more tamper-proof (provided adequate testing of various encryptions is done before hand, of course). The flurry of concern is to be expected, as it is an emerging technology, but the prerogative of the US in passing this proposition, is admirable. If the technology is adopted now, it’ll overall be a great step towards the facilitation of many other rudimentary processes – the installation of chips on groceries and other items as a way of eliminating bar codes or even check out registers, is one possibility that I have heard proposed. Such technology would naturally evolve into more secure and speedy formats; meanwhile, a test of this technology’s new potential can only put society on the way towards a greater plane of technological integration.

Agnes * Mazur